Let's say my opponent (with a fully loaded Opportunist card) rolls a 7, needing a 10 to hit. He takes 3 opportunist tokens to modify the roll, resulting in the needed 10.

So how and in what order do these interact? Can I PC the newly-created 10? (And if so, what happens to the Opportunist tokens?)

Or can I only PC the 7?

I'd say no.

By allowing your opponent to use his Opportunist tokens, you are tacitly admiting that you will let the roll stand. After all, the feat makes specific reference to adding the tokens after the roll; if is said something like "during" or "while rolling", then there would be less wiggle room.


So, I'd rule the appropriate course of action to be:

1) Your opponent rolls a 7, you say, "You miss"
2) Your opponent starts to reach for Opportunist tokens
3a) You say, "Oh, if you are going to do that, I'll make you reroll and hopefully you'll crit miss or something." or;
3b) You don't do anything, let your opponent use the tokens to make the attack succeed, and take the hit

I'd say Opportunist goes into effect only after the re-roll.

This has come up before and the deputies are correct

Apologies for the duplication of effort. I searched the forums before posting (to no avail), but I fully endorse "Searching before Posting."

Thanks for the super-quick and incisive replies!

I wasn't trying to call out searching. I usually save that for when it's something that really comes up a lot. But both deputies posting made it sound like they were not 100% sure of the answer. But I remember when the card came out, this was brought up (though it may have been on ye olde WK site) - that's all I was saying.

Can i use Lunge and Flurry? LOL!!!!




Don't hit me please

Can I outwit a damage reducer before poison takes effect?




YAAAAAAAAAAARRGH!

This here - that's why I don't buy you guys nice things anymore!

When did this happen??!!

Could be worse. Which Rules Deputy did i make spit soda out on his keyboard? That was funny. Interestingly enough i believe it was a lunge question

Oh that was you
int his thread http://www.hcrealms.com/forum/showth...ighlight=lunge

Back to the seriousness. Another Opportunist question:

If I roll a 10, can I add 2 opportunist tokens to create a critical hit—with all the attendant benefits of a crit hit—as the new attack roll of 12 previously meant that one had rolled double sixes?

No.

The Player's Guide is your friend (and always in my sig)

Ooh, good to know. The knockback bit was going to be my next quesion.