What to do? We lynch Sky.

Vote: SkyKushryd

You're all honestly writing too much off as "He's a noob, we'll just deal with it." He's said multiple times already that he read several complete games before playing in his first one, so he knows how the game is played. He is probably thus on equal footing as a semi-experienced player.

Beyond that, if any of you had the ability to ask the mod a question (ANY QUESTION AT ALL), would you have failed to achieve anything at all in 3 nights?

I'm not buying it. It's like claiming cop but failing to produce any results, simply distracting the town and wasting its resources.

Rokk's autopsy also proves that I was right, he was telling the truth, and that h2raider and Sky (who almost got that lynch off of him on Day 1-2) should be getting a lot more flack than they are.

...that and "Rokk_Krinn" is not a video game character.
I want to check out h2raider's claim of Declain Cain, not waste my time on an ID that I'm fairly certain is bogus.

As I have said multiple times: I believed Rokk.
And I let up on him.

O.K., Rokk isn't a video game player.
He's a Mafia game player.

Don't you think TBB thinks Mafia is a "Game Worth Playing"???

If this were an sstral, ABF, even a Thawmus (after this DBZ series) game I'd be more inclined to believe you.

However, your claim is much too far-fetched at this point in the game and you have done more harm than good.

How have I done any harm at all???

I got a couple of bad answers to a bad questions.

All that proves is that I suck at this power.

I think you are trying overly hard to get me lynched.

Lynch get_1

Following get_1's lead right now...things don't add up and there is only one way to find out.

vote:sky

a dead cop is better than a dumb cop.
lynch sky

Let's not get personal here...if he turns out to really be town and Rokk, we ALL look stupid for getting rid of someone who could have potentially gotten us VERY far in this game.

Just right now, I don't think he has our best interests at heart.

If you were town, you should have said "a dumb cop is better than a dead cop." The town always wants a cop alive, even if the individual isn't good at playing that role.

But the point is that I suspect Sky isn't being truthful with us.

Someone should look into batfink for his above comment though. It may have just been a moment of carelessness, or it may have been a Freudian slip that belies his true intentions.

I think it is a malicious statement.

Even a dumb cop can stumble onto a mafioso every once in a while.

A dead cop can't even try.

Man, I am torn. On one hand, Sky has seemingly been keeping us distracted for a few days, and while his questions have been 3-wishes-Genie-worthy, at least he tried last night. On the other hand... Sky pretty much cleared me on Day 2, so if he's Mafia, I'm pretty much screwed.

I'm gonna go out on a limb and Lynch: batfink.

If Sky gets close, I'll jump on the train, but honestly, it looks like we are punishing a player for not using his power correctly.

Actually, it is more "what kind of questions are you asking?" when we gave him templates to use. That is what is bothering me...

Honestly, I thought his question last night looked pretty straight-forward. It took The Darkstone himself to point out that a Lynch Vote could constitute a Kill power to the Mod.

Although, technically...lynching is not really a kill power. It is a vote, not a kill.

That's exactly my issue with him.

If you had a power to ask the mod one question every night, what would be the first thing that pops into your head? "Is ____ town?" After Day 2 when he called out Rokk and Rokk_Krinn claimed, the natural response would be to ask "Is Rokk_Krinn ToeJam & Earl?" Instead he supposedly goes off and asks about DarqFeonix, someone totally unrelated.

We provided him black and white questions to use. He doesn't use them.

I emphasized the "supposedly" up there because I don't think he has that power at all. You have all written it off as him "being a noob."

I'm telling you, that excuse shouldn't fly with SkyKushryd. He's done his research in how mafia games are supposed to be played. He's said so himself.

If it were someone like MSU who has been supposedly using his power in the way Sky has told us he has been, we would call MSU out in a second on probably lying about his power to lead us about.

But it does result in the person being killed.