Especially anyone not willing to vote for him on D3, as there will likely be some mafia joining the bandwagon today to claim innocence.

This was my list of people who didn't vote for him on D3:

CarlosMucha (captured now)
ghosta (was silenced)
Grinner
Mr Stranger
Quebbster
veguto

I voted for him. Twice. I just removed my vote both times, first because votes were piling up a little too quickly and then because get_1 asked me to. I should probably have put it back on before going to bed, but hindsight is 20/20.
But Grinner and veguto do seem like interesting candidates then...

Vote Stranger

And we shall call it the case of the gutted fish

Typically in an 18 person game, how many are towns, mafia, and neutrals? I'm not asking about this game in particular, just what the average percentage is so I can have a general idea.

Depends a little on the mod, but usually about 20-25% Mafia, and slightly less Neutrals.
normalview's last game also had 18 players - 5 Mafia, 3 Neutrals, 10 Town, so we might see a similar breakdown here.

And (hopefully) my last newb question(s), what do neutrals do? I'm sure they do different things, but what are their normal roles? I remember playing the game in college where we had the nurse and the sheriff and a few roles like that, are those the neutrals, or are they vastly different depending on the mod? Just curious.

Neutrals are roles who either win simply by surviving to the end of the game (and thus can win both with the Mafia and the Town), or have some other odd win condition - the Serial Killer needs to kill everyone else, a Bounty Hunter needs to find a specific player etc.

It is also worth noting that Silver Lantern only voted after regular majority was akready reached, and when explicitly asked to do so.

Mr Stranger (4): Quebbster, charlesx, ChiRocker, michiganj24


With 15 remaining, 8 needed for majority.

That's true, but I wasn't online much yesterday Quebs. Today should be a different story, unless something gets crazy at work.

Trying to deflect much from the fact that you twice conveniently took your vote off Mr. Stranger?

Anyone else not seeing the Scarecrow fog thingy in the write up? Did someone mess with you Rokk? Or am I just missing it?

Nope. Just pointing out the fact that of the people who did vote yesterday, you are the most suspicious to me. And I have already explained why I removed my vote.
Oh, and I can't help noticing that you haven't voted yet...

But if I do, you'll merely accuse me of voting after being asked to tomorrow...

I mean it's not like the mafia would likely silence him again to protect him is it?

Cause if that were the case, people wasting time with Mr. Stranger lynch trains would likely be scum partners am I right?

That has happened. Silencing a teammate to make them lynch immune is a valid tactic.
More common than that is scummos pretending to be silenced though - that happens a lot. If both Grinner and ghosta were silenced on day 2, that's the two silenced players right there, and Mr S was faking it.
*shrugs* I just want to get the votes on fast enough that we can get another train going if necessary after supermajority is met. If you have a better plan, I'd love to hear it - right now it looks like you are procrastinating though.

Yeah cause it's impossible that Ghosta or Grinner are lying right? And if Stranger is silenced, it's not like he can defend himself is it?

How do you know we'll need to get another lynch train going after supermajority is met Quebs? OMAC much bud?