You are currently viewing HCRealms.com, The Premier HeroClix Community, as a Guest. If you would like to participate in the community, please Register to join the discussion!
If you are having problems registering to an account, feel free to Contact Us.
I think it is okay to make it easier to grow the game by making dials on cards. Building synergistic teams is part of the fun. Currently, not being able to look at the dial unless you are making your own spreadsheets/database or separate website is bad.
I called the second part "abuse" because I believe that you should not get to reference dials during the game. If the figure is yours or not, I don't think you should be able to reference stat blocks during the game in competitive events.
I am going to be somewhat hypocritical and say I do look forward to referencing the stat blocks at sealed product events. I dislike that I am not really sure what the pieces on my squad are capable of.
Thats reasonable and for the most part* the way I will be playing at home.
*(except for the team building part as I build all the teams and my son chooses the team he wants to play)
The caution to players and judges that play at public events is to realize that this is likely to be a hot topic with passionate view points that fall on different sides of the fence. Scheduling a conversation time that doesnt interrupt your play time (post-event/pre-event) where players can at least vent their beliefs might be wise for some groups.
"A Jester unemployed is nobody's fool." - The Court Jester "And so he says, I don't like the cut of your jib, and I go, I says it's the only jib I got, baby!
There's fourth option you didn't mention.
You get to see my dials, but I do not. I get to see your dials, but you do not.
That would be fun.
Seriously, though, I'm pretty much with you in assuming that either all or nothing would be the way to go, but probably for different reasons.
May main concern is quite selfish, actually. I don't want to have to be judging and deal with some man-child who thinks he's rather clever. He'll ask to look at his opponent's card and then "cleverly" pull some shenanigan to peek at the dial.
It could be "Oops...I seem to have accidentally dropped another card and it landed with the dial side up...again. My bad."
It could be just turning it around to catch a quick glance as he hands it back.
In any case, I foresee myself getting called over to deal with that.
It's an easy enough situation to handle, sure. Give the guy a warning the first time, and then a loss or a DQ for a future infraction.
If the guy's legitimately a butterfingers, then he can take measures to not do it again, like just sliding the cards across the table. (Heck, I'd even suggest that when issuing the warning.)
But while it is easy to handle, it's still not a pleasant thing I'd like to have to handle.
That said, I imagine that there will be a bunch of people who just allow the opponents to see the full card anyway.
That's not for different reasons than me. My other post was not an exhaustive list.
Quote : Originally Posted by Magnito
In other words, it's all Vlad's fault.
Quote : Originally Posted by Masenko
Though I'm pretty sure if we ever meet rl, you get a free junk shot on me.
Quote : Originally Posted by Thrumble Funk
Vlad is neither good nor evil. He is simply Legal.
Hm. I know there are several guys at our venue that use an Android HCRules app, and for the iOS side of things a few of us just have the PDFs of the PAC/Rulebook/Giant Size rules on our phones.
Just so anyone with iOS knows, there is an app on iphones that have the rules. Just search for MTN Clix and you should find it. Obviously it's just for games where in a venue where you can look at your phones, but it's there.
No battle plan survives contact with the enemy. - Helmuth von Moltke the Elder
I'd suggest checking with your player base to see how they feel first, to make sure you don't end up having some sort of mass exodus as a result. I personally wouldn't play at a venue that did that. I'm not trying to be offensive either, that's just my opinion on the matter and I'm probably not the only one who feels that way.
a mass exodus would mean... oh wait it's an hour drive to the nearest other clix venue... don't like it too bad. I don't like the choices wizkids make and have to put up with them.
The reason to put Dials on cards is it makes it easier for new players to get proficient with the game. In addition players will be able to team build with much more ease. Currently, I feel compelled to use this FINE website units section.
But you're not using the units section during the game.
Quote
I do think there will eventually be sideline abuse. Figures will be part of sideline that have no shot of joining the game just to look at dials, unless there is ruling banning that.
This is something I have significant concerns about. If I were in the Judge spot, I would never allow it without WK providing a ruling stating it's explicitly allowed. It's clearly against the "spirit of the game."
"It is a fool's prerogative to utter truths that no one else will speak." "Prove you have the strength and courage to be free."
Two thumbs down on the card format. Squish text all on one side of the card looks terrible. Dial on the card is ridiculous and not needed or wanted by most. This will be the first set I boycott.
“Nothing frightens me. I AM fear.” - Thaal Sinestro
Shared knowledge can live forever. Empowering you to live forever.
So since the new cards starting with Superior Foes will have the dials on the cards that you can reference with leisure, Is it ok now to check out older characters dials mid-game to see what our next click is or how many clix it has left?
I give a resounding Yes! If Wizkid's wants to be dumb and put dials on the back of cards in a game where the intentional design of the figures bases were initially created and engineered to conceal most of the dial, then why the hell not...They are morons, so let them suffer the consequences of their idiocy.
Wizkid's doesn't actually have a leg to stand on in this ruling in all honesty. Just as with real law they already set the precedent from here on out by allowing the viewing of the entire figures dial, so in essence it makes all subsequent rulings null and void.
Now granted they will probably take the low-road to save face for this terrible decision by using the argumentum ad verecundiam and allowing their irrelevant authority to add credibility to their claim being made. Which is why this is considered a fallacy in logic. But when does Wizkid's ever use logic for their ruling's? Hey Wizkid's do you even logic bro...?
Last edited by BigBlueBeast1982; 07/29/2016 at 01:12..
"Nearly all men can handle adversity, but if you want to test a man's character, give him power."-- Abraham Lincoln
"We buy things we don't need, with money we don't have, to impress people we don't like..."
Won't you actually have to just boycott all future sets? This is going to be the design on the card going forward for all of Heroclix. It would be weird to boycott one set, but then buy the others.
"He's Predator Smurf! Not Happy Smurf or Gleeful Smurf or even PMSing Smurfette! He's Predator Smurf! What kind of attitude do you think he's gonna have?" -Songwriterz-
I give a resounding Yes! If Wizkid's wants to be dumb and put dials on the back of cards in a game where the intentional design of the figures bases were initially created and engineered to conceal most of the dial, then why the hell not...They are morons let them suffer the consequences of their idiocy.
Wizkid's doesn't actually have a leg to stand on in this ruling in all honesty. Just as with real law they already set the precedent from here on out by allowing the viewing of the entire figures dial, so in essence it makes all subsequent rulings null and void.
Now granted they will probably take the low-road to save face for this terrible decision by using the argumentum ad verecundiam and allowing their irrelevant authority to add credibility to their claim being made. Which is why this is considered a fallacy in logic. But when does Wizkid's ever use logic for their ruling's? Hey Wizkid's do you even logic bro...?
Your "resounding yes" is irrelevant to the actual rules, though.
Quote : Originally Posted by Magnito
In other words, it's all Vlad's fault.
Quote : Originally Posted by Masenko
Though I'm pretty sure if we ever meet rl, you get a free junk shot on me.
Quote : Originally Posted by Thrumble Funk
Vlad is neither good nor evil. He is simply Legal.
Your "resounding yes" is irrelevant to the actual rules, though.
Considering that I'm a judge at a local venue; my "resounding yes" is in fact very relevant to the "actual" rules because I supersede them! My hypocrisy only goes so far, as I will not let terrible ruling's and horrible game design ruin this game on the local level. If they want to ruin the game on a national/competitive level then that's their prerogative.
I will take an all or nothing stance to this ruling. Either all character dials can be referenced by the player from Infinity Challenge to current or no dials can referenced by the players. I'm not allowing select figures or sets to have that distinct advantage, as it does nothing for the game but hurt it's legitimacy...
And as always Vlad your opinion is highly valued by me and I'm ever so grateful for your input as it always tends to further the discussion...
Last edited by BigBlueBeast1982; 07/29/2016 at 19:44..
"Nearly all men can handle adversity, but if you want to test a man's character, give him power."-- Abraham Lincoln
"We buy things we don't need, with money we don't have, to impress people we don't like..."
Considering that I'm a judge at a local venue; my "resounding yes" is in fact very relevant to the "actual" rules because I supersede them! My hypocrisy only goes so far, I will not let terrible ruling's and horrible game design ruin this game on the local level. If they want to ruin the game on a national/competitive level then that's their prerogative.
But hey Vlad, as always your opinion is highly valued by me and I'm ever so grateful for your input as it always tends to further evolve the discussion...
That doesn't even make sense. I have absolutely no clue where you're even getting anything about "hypocrisy" from.
Also, I think you're missing my point. The question posed in this thread was not "how do you do this at your venue?" It was "What is the rule on this?" You choosing to house rule it at your venue has no bearing on the answer to the question that was actually asked.
Quote : Originally Posted by Magnito
In other words, it's all Vlad's fault.
Quote : Originally Posted by Masenko
Though I'm pretty sure if we ever meet rl, you get a free junk shot on me.
Quote : Originally Posted by Thrumble Funk
Vlad is neither good nor evil. He is simply Legal.