Cult usually cannot recruit mafia....it breaks the mafia since the cult person will be able to out them all.

I believe Rokk was in that situation, sold out his mafia after recruited, and the game was won very fast.

Hence, Mafia cannot be recruited. Most likely, neither can the SKer since that again, upsets game balance.

@spworld - we have some clues in the write up as well as the vote on the outed cult member to dwindle our lists.

so it isn't random/blind.

Yep, that pretty much sums up my background.

I'm Diana Stanley. I am a redeemed cultist, meaning, I left the cult I was in (the one in this game, but prior to us playing), and wanted to make it a point to stop what they were doing, per my write up. Each night, I can search a player to see if they are cult or not and I cannot be recruited, because technically I am "one of them" because my character sort of snuck away from them. Alas, I am town and would feel no better than to get rid of them.

Unfortunately, my power has only actually worked once. Night 1, I targeted Ouchmaker, no real reason why, 14 is my favorite number, so that's who I chose. He came up as cult and I decided to keep it to myself, just because I didn't want any cult gunning for me that early in the game. I was planning on saying something about Ouchmaker the next day, but whoever the SKer is beat me to it and ate him at night or whatever. Now, what makes me wonder, is if he was the original cultist or not because he came up as cult the first night, but now we know Satu was cult too, so one of the two had to of stared the cult. And my guess is that it wasn't Firefly, a GI Joe character.

Now, for K-Ness, I targeted him 2 nights ago and my reply was "He is not a member of the cult". As of what happened last night, I don't know. But, that's what I know.

I figured I should probably tell you guys this now because I was blocked last night and I think whoever is in the cult was on to what my character can do.

So, yeah.

Yes, no arguement. I've been saying that all game (and you'll note there was no action from the Bat on N1 - which if I was an SK would've been forced randomized as an SK always has to kill). My point is if I'm sending out the Bat there, then I can't be the janitoring monster SK which people keep trying to twist this to be.

It was one of the earliest games on the Realms - the third one Peers ran and the one that caused him to leave for awhile as, yeah, it turned into a fiasco (I was recruited N1 and came out the next Day and outted the entire Mafia...leading to me being modkilled which folks backed me as an "iffy call"...game was called on account of rain. I think Peers has hated me ever since...or maybe before, who knows.)

1) never keep information like that to yourself in future games.

2) Night 1 there can only be one cult person - the cult leader.

3) Why are you only telling us this now? The cult, as far as games I have played in, don't have a kill power.

Where was this information before?

Hey, don't blame the player, blame the mod!

I remembered that game and in all games I have had with cults, I have made sure that the cults DO NOT recruit mafia or neutrals and that they don't turn into cops (not revealing how I do that, however...).

toughest - sorry, maybe I am blinded by my own theory but I don't believe you.

One, I don't think you are that trust worthy because yo udidn't vote for the outed cult member. Even though you were on. you said one thing and never said another thing.

two, I think you are part of the cult. I think you and Kness are in it. So I don't trust wha tyou are saying.

three, again, if you targeted cult on night 1, that means you found the cult leader. And you could have stopped it all. I doubt you would keep this information to yourself.

I'm sorry. I kept this to myself because I didn't know if there was a cult SK, which we still don't know, and I was worried of getting hacked off at night. But, as my power has only worked once, I don't think it would have made that big of difference. And as of night 1, I didn't say there was any more than 1 cultist, I just got really lucky targeting the only cultist at the time. I kept it to myself because I wanted to see what he would do and sort of watch for a night or so, but since he was killed by the SK, I didn't think it was necessary to reveal the info since I had nobody else to show who was cult affiliated. Do you see what I mean?

@Rokk - on this point, I'm willing to agree with you. My supposition that Mal was a Vig, is strictly due to the way ZYX is doing the write ups. The 'going in to take him out' bit reads like a hit, and he was Town which is why I said Vig.

Vote Furby Frank Because we haven't seen two-face in the write up for a long time. If he was recruited, perhaps it messed with his power? I want targets for his actions. Why has he not shown up in the write ups?

Also, in the interest in full disclosure... I was given a fake claim. I know, I know, not only am I a guiding, clue copping, PGO, but now I also have a fake claim? Yep. I did.

Solomon Grundy. But I didn't want to use it because after night 2 death toll, people would believe my real claim more than a fake.

Anyways, I share this bit of info because I think it may help find our Cult leader. Name claims are not solid.

Plus, at what point did Ouch die? Based on him being Cult Leader would he have had time to build a Cult which we know exists?

This is all too convenient with the votes on Kness, Toughest....why didn't you say this first?

He died via ???? on night 2.

He also JKs....

why your refusal to vote for Kness? Just out of curiosity.....

I'm saying, what if since Ouchmaker died the 2nd night, he probably recruited Satu night 1. And since this was such a big game, maybe the mod allowed the last cult member allowed to recruit, that being Satu.

And let's be honest, if someone guns for someone Day 1/Day 2, most people will think that they are trying to set someone up, so I kept it until I thought it was a problem.

I realize if I am not lynched, I will probably be dead at night, but I had to present this all soon.

He died via the SKer, supposedly. Whatever the monster is.