Someone wants to trade me the collosal Spectre for BlackHand chase and Bat/Cat duo. Is this a good trade

I'd say you're overpaying by throwing in the bat/cat duo. just my 2 cents tho...

I say it is fair because it will cost him $15-$20 just to ship the thing

I personally few trades based upon what I want and what I'm getting not just on value. If you really I mean really want the Colossal Spectre and your willing to trade it for those two pieces and you won't feel bad about doing then go ahead and do it. If that isn't something that your going to be ok with then don't do it. Value is all relative anyway.

well, I've always wanted Spectre, however Black Hand was my very first chase I've ever pulled, and I did so on my birthday.

You know what, just give me both, and I'll figure something out.

If you want it then that is fine. Personally, I know I can use Black Hand in more games than Spectre.

if you have to question the trade, usually it's not.

I own both Spectre used 1 sits on my book shelf and owned for 2 years. Black hand used at least 4-5 times owned what a couple months. Bats and cats already used 2 times and lots of fun. Its up to you to decide thow but its clear to me which ones wont collect dust.

Like most post-ers are saying, value is in the eye of the beholder.

Spectre is an awesome sculpt, one of my favorites of ANY fig, hands-down the best Colossal (although Dr M may challenge that!) but I have only used him twice since I got him the summer he was released.

Black Hand and Bats/Cats, however, I have already used each in 2 games since I got them. When you consider I have only been to 8 tournaments since BatB was released, this is a high usage rate!

Even if I did not have Spectre, unless I had an extra Black Hand and Bats/Cats, I would not make the trade.

Just like everyone is saying... it's up to you. If you really really want spectre then take the trade. I personally don't like using the huge collosal figures unless its a few friends messing around. I'de rather just play a few nice theme teams for that amount of points.

yeah I figure I could just amazon Spectre sometime