Well that's why I missed it, it's not exactly clear is it? I mean she didn't even say "I'm" Starmie...

Its as if I say any random word at the end of a sentence, and then claim that I role-claimed by that word, hairballx.

Guys I'm hairballx, didn't you all see my claim...

I am not hairballx btw, I just made that up, so I'm sure it's not even a pokemon.

SL, she said it - she didn't point a neon glow sign and say "LOOK AT ME! LOOK AT ME! I'm STARMIE!" but she said it.

It's a moot point you are trying to make something out of...it's like your Pax or something.

Yes I tend to argue every point... stupid law school training...

And she didn't need to point a neon sign, but to be cryptic and say a word at the end of a sentence without alluding to the fact that it's remotely even a role claim means absolutely nothing to me, sorry if you see it as me being overly picky and argumentative, hairballx.

No need to insult me by calling me Pax though.

"STAN! Chemical attack now!"

But aren't you curious to at least see if we can trust Tyro's day copping or not?

*spits on SL and flips him the bird*

Curious, yes.

But he picked Quebbs out of no where. he never explained WHY he chose Quebbs. Maybe if he had chosen Truffles, I would be more inclined to believe him, but right now - not sure.

I agree that voting for Truffles and then sending in Quebs for the copping seems odd, but WE HAVE TO KNOW if his info is reliable. If it is, it's a great tool, if it's not, then at least we know to move on and look into tyro if necessary.

The alternative is we don't get a lynch and play the same he said/she said game tomorrow, that kinda stall and vagueness plays to the mafia's benefit IMO.

If Tyro is lying about Quebs, then the Vig should kill him or we can look into him tomorrow in case he's not a sane cop.

No, we don't HAVE to know by lynching maybe our Guide. If Tyro is telling the truth, then he went about disclosing his information in the wrong way (and not coming on and backing ANY of it up) because right now, i don't 100% trust it.

ok i voted on Truffs while i was waiting for my result from the mod. it took a couple of hours for him to get back to me, why not vote for someone else while i'm waiting. i didn't expect a train to pull out or the station on truffs but it did. once i got my result i switched my vote and tried to get others to follow suit, a couple of times, before i claimed myself with the reason why we should be voting quebs.

of course, there is a chance i'm insane/paranoid cop, since you are never told if your insane. well at least, i don't know if my character is. i personally, plead the fifth. why quebs? random choice. contrary to rokk's believe i don't go around cashing in revenge tokens although you know all of you should have one on you by now. although, sky is in trouble if he's in a game with me and i have a death power!!

looks like if i live, next copping MSU.

That's funny. I tend to view Guide claims as "safe" claims by Mafia.

I agree, and given his initial defeatist "well that sucks, I was looking forward to this game," response by Quebs, it seems the most fishy to me.

Bring it Tyro....the day cop is the most broken power in the game that we have ever seen.

You have given me NO REASON to trust you on Day 1.

Or maybe I just realized how bad the whole thing looked through someone else's eyes.