You are currently viewing HCRealms.com, The Premier HeroClix Community, as a Guest. If you would like to participate in the community, please Register to join the discussion!
If you are having problems registering to an account, feel free to Contact Us.
I really am amazed at the last 3 or 4 (excluding legions) sets that UDe has produced and their effect and archetype changes to the game. And not just the constructed portion, but a vibrant limited format as well. OUtside of a handful of bustedness....
Maybe that's just the devil we have to deal with if UDE has to churn out sets every 90 days and we want sets that are interesting and powerful.
The hard bannings were the first time through the process. UDE just needs to commnicate an Omelette policy on Vs. Production. Something like:
"You can't make an omelette without breaking eggs. We can't push out this many sets at this speed and make it interesting without letting a few goofs out the door. When the community uncovers those goofs, we'll act quickly and decisively and cards will get banned. Expect it and don't bemoan the loss of one card when we're trying to keep an environment filled with thousands of other cards rewarding and fulfilling."
Also, there's a bit of a 'good' trend in the recent sets of focusing on team synergy, and rewarding mono-team play. It's a little easier to keep "mono-teams" safe from degeneracy than a mish mash of combos. An increase in team stamp effects [especially with Dr. Light eliminating some of the ways to getting around team stamps ... ditto Detective Chimp].
There will still be some cards that need to be banned.
I'd rather see a couple cards get banned then have cards that are unplayable and thus "as good as banned".
in all seriousness, frankie is a pretty busted card outside of limited, and even then she is still very strong. I think UDE should take action on this card before sydney. llast time they waited too long to take action they kinda' made a few players mad.
Quote : Originally Posted by CaptainCuba (paraphrased)
There was a card banned, and the next day we had a PCQ and were told we couldn't use that card. The T.O. CHOSE TO MAKE THE BAN IMMEDIATE.
I'm pretty sure that's completely outside the bounds of his authority. Can anyone confirm or deny?
Quote : Originally Posted by CaptainCuba(paraphrased)
It wasn't until a PRO out there CREATED A NEW ACCOUNT to spoil a decklist that we really knew how busted Frankie.dec and all it's variations could be. Why do the more casual PCQs have to suffer through this?!?!?
It's Wednesday, the PCQs are on the weekend, the decklist (which only select teams had) wasn't posted until today. How is an immediate ban going to hurt at all?
THEY DIDN'T HAVE THE DECKLIST UNTIL TODAY!!!
Irrelevant and ignorant. What about anyone who's playing in that PCQ who discovered that deck on their own? You're hurting them. You also assume UDE will see this thread tonight and say, "You know what? Those guys are completely right, let's ban it!" UDE has almost never worked that fast.
Quote : Originally Posted by Jaxxin
Banning Attend or Die does not fix the problem. Trust me.
No one should ever trust someone who simply says, "This is truth. Trust me." Really. Don't even bother trying.
in all seriousness, frankie is a pretty busted card outside of limited, and even then she is still very strong. I think UDE should take action on this card before sydney. llast time they waited too long to take action they kinda' made a few players mad.
You wouldn't be saying that if Frankie was a SKRULL!!!
we're not a hundred percent sure she ISN'T (or wasn't) a skrull. but fair is fair, she is more broken than all of the other skrulls...... it's time to inspire her demise.
I'm pretty sure that's completely outside the bounds of his authority. Can anyone confirm or deny?
Irrelevant and ignorant. What about anyone who's playing in that PCQ who discovered that deck on their own? You're hurting them. You also assume UDE will see this thread tonight and say, "You know what? Those guys are completely right, let's ban it!" UDE has almost never worked that fast.
No one should ever trust someone who simply says, "This is truth. Trust me." Really. Don't even bother trying.
Why would I lie about a PCQ?
Ignorant? No team would let anyone run the deck at a PCQ this close to Sydney. I doubt anyone there would have run it. Even if ONE person was, isn't better to hurt the single player than the other 30? It's a BUSINESS decision, for the good of the game.
Do you know who Jaxxin is? I'd sooner listen to his claim, than pretty much anyone else on here. If there's a final list somewhere, he probably had a hand in it. Or if there's a counter deck, he probably had a hand in it. You can argue with me all you want, I play decks with Rocket Racer in them what do I know...but to argue with his statement about the power level of a card is pretty silly.
Ive said it before in some of my post Dr Light messages, and Ill say it again. I am very suprised they didnt ban Frankie along with the Doctor. She just makes games unfun to play. The game should be about playing around Power-ups, Acro Dodge effects, and hoping they dont have a stun back effect, not sitting contently in your chair waiting 15 minutes for your opponent to finish their build phase. I consider myself a competitive player, but I still want to have fun with the games I am playing. If Im not having fun with VS System, first It will upset me, and then I will adjust and move to another TCG. Right now I am hoping UDE doesnt force me to adjust...
Ive said it before in some of my post Dr Light messages, and Ill say it again. I am very suprised they didnt ban Frankie along with the Doctor. She just makes games unfun to play. The game should be about playing around Power-ups, Acro Dodge effects, and hoping they dont have a stun back effect, not sitting contently in your chair waiting 15 minutes for your opponent to finish their build phase. I consider myself a competitive player, but I still want to have fun with the games I am playing. If Im not having fun with VS System, first It will upset me, and then I will adjust and move to another TCG. Right now I am hoping UDE doesnt force me to adjust...
exactly, YES, finally some1 else says it, I hated pcla(eventhough I ran x-stall), every opp I faced, their build phase took 4ever, I mean, its like players said, F**k attacking, lets just take a 25 min build phase and win on turn 3 or 4, VS should be about combat, not stupid combo decks that win on turn 3 without having to attack. WOW all the way for now.
yeah VS is getting a bit silly with all this. ban frankie and attend or die (which isn't all that good anyway with both swamp and soul world out there, its only purpose is to enable brokenness). then maybe i'll be inspired to build VS decks instead of old school SWCCG (the game that's ALL about battling).
The best part of this thread is the NEW NEGABOMB thread trying to combo Negabomb-Thor-Unexpected Mutation. The world needs more of that and less of this.
I still maintain that Jason Hager is way better than Frankie Raye, and should be banned along with Frankie.
I would like to share a meme that me and my friends have been infected with. The belly laughs it causes may save your life.
Every time we open a fortune cookie, we follow it with "in bed". I think I picked it up from Mary Van Tyne or something, but it spreads to other things if you let it.
So, let's play. It might lighten the mood in here.
"I still maintain that Jason Hager is way better than Frankie Raye..."
Netdecking is a necessary evil, I know that. But at the beginning of the thread, all we had were VAGUE and UNDEFINED "Frankie needs to get banned" comments. That's why I #####ed about people thinking outside the box.
It sounded more like people complaining that TNNB/HV/DoomCrisis/FLAVOR OF THE MONTH was going to get the shaft from Frankie.dec.
It wasn't until a PRO out there CREATED A NEW ACCOUNT to spoil a decklist that we really knew how busted Frankie.dec and all it's variations could be. Why do the more casual PCQs have to suffer through this?!?!?
It's Wednesday, the PCQs are on the weekend, the decklist (which only select teams had) wasn't posted until today. How is an immediate ban going to hurt at all?
THEY DIDN'T HAVE THE DECKLIST UNTIL TODAY!!!
So ok, save the precious PC that only effects 300 of you, but I'm sure that there will be more than 300 people at local PCQs throughout the country that will feel disgusted when some random netdecks this list and proceeds to ruin their first OP experience.
CC
It really sounds like you're overexaggerating your PCQ situation. Except for me and a couple other people, there's pretty much no one in my area particularly involved in the online Vs. community. I just cannot honestly imagine that there is going to be ANY PCQ ANYWHERE that's going to suddenly become overrun with these decks.
In my experience, people don't bring these types of decks to PCQs, even if they are aware of them. They still bring an easier to play curve deck like TNNB, Crisis Doom, or Checkmate, or their own random deck like Spider-Friends. Even if there are people in your area in tune enough to have discovered this thread and manage to prepare a deck for this weekend, how many could it possibly be, one or two guys? What are the odds you will even face them in the swiss portion, and what are the odds that the people who find out about the deck are actually good enough to play it right?
I understand that having to play against these decks at a PCQ would be frustrating, but stop derailing the more important issue in this thread.
Aside: PCQs aren't casual, because there is money on the line. You can play whatever deck you want, but I will prepare for a PCQ with the intention of winning the $250. Yes, I want to have fun doing it, but it's a competitive event and I will treat it as such.