I completely agree. What makes some games are running jokes that everyone remembers. Who doesn't know WAIT UNTIL 10 IT'S IMPORTANT or any of the various running jokes from game threads.

I do that all the time.

I even put things that I receive in the write up.

I can't wait for someone to actually include a borg cat in their game.

That was one of my favorite parts of BTTF4.

When I killed BigBro and my character was all like "We don't need neutral investigators anymore."

Depends which would help less.

I generally either have the investigators do nothing or they learn something but they have no idea who they were randomized to. Once I reminded the cop what his affliation was when he didn't send his pm.

Misdirectors, silencers, etc I'll generally randomize because it helps the mafia and I'm secretly rooting for the mafia in every game.

I've always planned to "randomize" somebody towards a PGO if they don't send their target for several nights.

Me too.

I always root for the funniest people.

Like I was rooting for the Hellions to win FMM2, and Hulk to win FMM3.

Lol, i was rooting for the town in Resident Evil Mafia even though i was a serial killer, i think i actually started pretending to be their vig and started killing off the mafia but then tried to turn on the town, only to be betrayed by the snake, damn him

Just a tid bit, mods should keep in mind that if you realize an imbalance or a problem with the game, feel free to tweak it mid-game. If you've balanced the game well, it should only be a minor tweak anyway and won't hose any one player. Hidden triggers are perfect for this.

Okay, CONSTRUCTIVE criticism requested on my first game.

I did not play it, but i heard a lot of talk about it, and people whining for it to be open, therefore it must have been good

your game was great! lot of posts! lots of people, lots of things happen!

Avengers Under Siege is over and Zemo has taken it upon himself to give the results.

Result:MOE successfully take over the Avenger's Mansion

Winners:
Uknown352 - Baron Zemo
Lofcutus - Piledriver
madslaust - Absorbing Man
Vevilaughs - Mr. Hyde
kontrol - Wrecker
dbauers - Titania

It's your first one so from my POV, I could tell that you had some growing pains, but I had inside info. As far as the final result, it all turned up smelling roses. I'd have added the caveat to Samwise that he couldn't target the same player twice. Aside from that, I'd say it was fine. You hit your stride with the write-ups, too. The hardest part is gauging how much info to give out and what bits to give. I think you did pretty well for your first time.

What's the best way to randomly assign roles?