[quote=rorschachparadox;8512403]Having trouble RP?

Only scum mess with quotes. String him up!

Real thoughts: gfish is probably the only neutral in the game. Forget his real allignment. He is now neutral and we should approach him as such. He is both useful, but dangerous.

Rokk is probably scum. My reasoning being the Vinsini circle logic: he is to dangerous to have on the other side, so one should recruit him. Yet everybody knows one would recruit him due to that, so one shouldn't. But everybody knows one should, and wont, therefore they won't suspect one of recruiting him.

Phew.

And also, colonial Bob is a good recruit choice.

leave vote with Darq.

Iceman, I'll bite.

[quote=rorschachparadox;8512403]Hah. I didn't tell anyone to lynch me.

Our posts are just a tad bit different, sir. At least, I believe so.

I was actually putting myself down there but take it how you want.

Back around, catching up. Wednesday is frisbee day.

There's a day for that?

I am willing to stay in, of course. I was willing to die to avoid being a sticking point and have the whole next day phase a debate over whether to lynch me.

There are all sorts of Days... I miss Banana Donut day (Thursday's) at Lamar's on Sixth Ave, or Santa Fe.. ::Sigh::

Okay I think I agree colonial would be a great recruit.

Vote CB

Why do you keep twisting what I'm saying? My initial post did three things:
1) mention (in the form of a question, asking for confirmation, because I wasn't certain) that I felt posting a way to approach the game isn't solely a town action, because it's also something mafia can do to participate without giving up much information.
2) state that your claim of listing potential mafia picks first makes you town is... dubious (like you said yourself, it was obvious)
3) build on an idea you created

None of those is saying you're mafia. None of them is saying I think you're mafia. You just presented some things as strong evidence of your townieness, and I stated my disagreement that those proved much.

That being said, I'm now trying to figure out where I stand on your lynch, after your PGO claim.

But won't lynching Gfish give us information? Unless you think there's nobody else that can provide the conversation you feel he does, you have to at least consider it, right?

This is ultimately the main reason I'm considering voting for you. I'd guess you're town, but I'd rather not have your alignment coming up again every day, so it might still be worth it.

Still thinking. Vanilla is new territory, and while interesting, it also seems very brain-burny.

If I was don and we are assuming a 5 Person Mafia I would draft:

Rokk or Darq as a ringleader type.
Vlad, CaptainNifty, or ENS in the hopes they could fly under the radar.
Silver or Immortal as a combative type. (Throw me in here).
Magnito or JoH of CBob as a two way player who garners town trust.

My thoughts on GFish are that he wouldn't try this gambit now if mafia or he would solidly be in that last group.

I would probably pick the first of each grouping if I was don if we want a true list.

I too often have scum vibes for the others (Linkor etc) or butt heads with some (RP) of straight up do not have a feel for the rest (CaptainNifty).

I trust no one here right now.

I don't think there is a lynch, but I will tally votes shortly. Game closed for now.

Day 1 Vote Count
gfish (4): vlad, CapNifty, gfish, raven
Rokk (1): JoH
Bob (2): adam, Ens

No majority was reached. You have until 10:30 EST tomorrow to get actions in.

Night 1
Immortal_Raven is dead. He was town.

Day 2 starts now. With 15, 8 is majority. You have 24 hours.

So... ens... whatcha got?