I told folks more than once he was the blonde girl that turned out to be Spoiler...or had a connection to that, at least.

Yes. I tweaked anything I thought needed a bit of tweaking. Dark gifts sometimes needed a bit of darkness. A couple of things I added % chances to also (IE Fredwood's PGO)

Good until you started focusing on Untargetable Phoenixfire.

Nope, it was just a matter of me not reading everything correctly.

I must be considered a real throw in the mafia world if I was killed night one :]

Or maybe even a threat!

Yeah, the mafia took you down without hesitation! Cthulhu apparently has beef with Condiments.

A couple thoughts:

1) "Town if investigated" maybe shouldn't have had Toughest show as Town when dead.

2) A Don with 3 lives...go read the feud over Zygon in Order of the Stick for thoughts on that. It's a brutal battle of attrition.

Now, throw in rezzes, a Townie with multiple lives, a Cult leader who could have multiple lives and a PGO? It may sound whiney but that was just a heavy disbalance towards certain roles having a chance (yeah, myself included).

Yeah, that was a surprise thing I had on my home sheets, but wasn't on the sent out role. It was supposed to be there though.

3 lives does feel like a lot, but without it I felt that perhaps the mafia was a bit underpowered. Cthulhu needed to be big and bad, and that was my attempt to do so. The first death awakened Cthulhu, the second ruined his skin suit, and the 3rd to actually defeat the beast.

I'd never used a PGO before. It was super easy to lynch SP, and you could win with him still alive, but you didn't know that. I figure, if nothing else, I made a mistake in not telling you that.

The Terrible Old Man role was probably a bit much. A lot of my townies had kill powers, which, when writing the game, gave it a a good sense of balance.

The town had a lot of killing potential, if they were careful early and a mason group to coordinate with, the SK had a possible partner, a few people they could win with, and some handy kills. The mafia had a janitor and some recruitments, to go with upgraded powers they could earn. The cult had nothing but a recruiting and the ability to become an avatar of Yog-Sothoth, and a kill, should their leader go down instead of the ability to recruit.

I'm sure things could have been more close to a center, but I felt I at least gave everyone a fighting chance.

Anything else people liked/disliked?

I loved the story, and the writeups, kinda wish there was a way I could read it like a novel..

Same. Well thought out zyxba. This was a very fun game. Can't wait for the "sequel"? to come out!

I loved reading along! Wish I hadn't tried to cop the PGO night 2 (especially when he outed himself the next day). Had tons of fun watching the twists and turns, and congrats to the cult on the win! I wish I would've kept myself alive long enough for my alignment copping to be of some use!

I also enjoyed the interwoven stories, zyx. You did well making the Lovecraft characters fit in at the Asylum.

Yea, I read through the proboards. I had pretty much come to the conclusion you were cult by the end of the day phase we spent arguing with Rokk and MSU, but I didn't want to say I thought you were cult because then I still wanted you to bodyguard me. I also got the feeling that Rokk and MSU were scum, so I didn't want to side with them either.

For anyone curious:

The mafia proboard:

http://cthulthuvsbats.proboards.com/...?board=general

Well I guess I Should have been more liberal with my spell use, as I didn't do anything for the first 2 or 3 nights, trying to get a feel for the game (I didn't want to go firing blindly killing and blocking indiscriminately), until I blocked FF which made me think Q was a guide when he was able to succeed, then I doctored Adam when he outed himself as the doc, which proved to be a waste as he was being body guarded by K-ness. Although, even if I did use all my spells from day one, I don't think I would have been able to use them all anyway, as I had 2 of the lawyering spells left, the kill spell, and the other doctor spell. The night Rokk was killed I was trying to guide him, so the RB makes sense but I never knew, because I rarely got a success or failure notice from night to night.

I guess the only things I did that made any difference was to make myself untargetable when I did, because I figured people would think I was the JK, and the banishment and lawyring down of Disco.

Also, Z, the night I targeted San, was I misdirected into MSU, or was that how you were explaining someone from the GI Joe universe.

Also, what was the deal w/ the Rats and the guards on day 1?