Roles, por favor? Interested to see some of the earlier deaths

the whole point, SL, was that I didn't want the riddle out there at all. It had nothing to do with the riddle itself, it was that I didn't want the idea of a riddle out there.

1) BC I didn't want Wade to have an immediate role claim
2) paranoia.

I enjoted thos game, thsnks msu

Thanks for a good game Charlie, am still gonna play the next one......as Mim........who is gonna be the wickedly awesome serial killer........who is still drunk

10 players basically puts it at around the 33% mark of the game (ie: for almost 1/3'rd of the game, the Mafia was needed to lynch their Don).

Yes, people did try to get every vote on DF at once but inevitably someone - not always just adamical - would switch off...and I remember trying to lynch adamical. So plenty of folks tried to push it further...it just wasn't going to happen.

However, there's a telling line in your statement Charlie: "You all call it unfair. I say what Magnito is saying." Ah, so you'll totally discount what a great majourity are pointing out as long as you have one little thread to hang on to as justification.

You run great games. Not all of them are of them are goin to be masterpieces. There may be a reason this time so many folks are pointing out flaws.

Honestly, you're not a real mod until you've created a role or mechanic that broke your game. Pretty much all of the seasoned mods have. You try something new, and sometimes, it doesn't end up being quite as balanced as it seemed when you were creating it. No matter how many games you've run, there will always be mistakes to learn from.

I personally think MSU hit the nail on the head when he said it was the loss of the extra Nightkillers way early. Combined with the inter-scum back-and-forth, this could have just as easily been a Town curbstomp with the Mafia complaining about the unlimited rezzings

Absolutely. We've all done it. We've all had experiments in our games that were great successes but we've also had abysmal failures. The trick though, as you note, is to learn from them (eg: I wouldn't use a role like Jareth again or I'd not totally derail with "too much oni."). Sometimes that also means swallowing some pride with the crow but it also makes the next games even better.

I've never made anything unbalanced in a mafia game. Ever.


*slides Chrono Trigger out of view*

Yeah Kenny would never make a Mafia don who's a mafia traitor or anything...

And sometimes all the balance in the world won't save you from a perfect storm with the actions that are sent in. Never know when two people are going to target a PGO, or when Chirocker is going to turn Rokk into a night 1 PGO. It's all in fun and we learn.

Didn't Pax have you as a hidden Don for the DC75th mafia? I got taken out early, but that ended up being a good game.

I created that role for Silver

That was one of my favorite roles ever. So much fun watching MSU squirm on the proboards! Up there with Deadpool in Kenny's games, Sirio Forrel in the GoT game, Webstor in Masters of the Universe, The bulletproof SK in IR's Comedian game, I could go on and on... Ahhh so many good roles!

I was just telling Kedryn about the hilarity of Chi turning Rokk into a PGO, never realizing that he was killing himself.