Aranatta and KJ have to be masons with a role restriction that they get mod-killed if they don't post together. Three is a row back-to-back now.

I'm at work at the moment, so I'm less verbose than I'd like, but I'll also notch up the heat with a vote: justphilthy.

You caught us!

Well, we definitely did now...

Brrreak????

Welp, there goes Aranatta!

I honestly expected to get Night Killed night 1 LOL

So did I. And I got you guys talking, so I'm quite happy I called you out.

Justp is at sufficient pressure, but in the absence of a response from him, I don't think I would lynch. It's early enough and we're ahead in terms of deaths. Just my thoughts for that possibility.

I agree with the no lynch at this time, the reasoning is good enough for pressure to me, but way too much speculation to ready the rope.

Pleas don't start that again... I Really want to see if I have a day kill.. Lol

Uh, doesn't saying "hey, let's not actually lynch him" completely negate the concept of putting pressure on JP?

Actually, I would be fine with lynching JustPhilthy. At this point, the mafia / sk might not have figured out whether or not there is a town theme, and may feel uncomfortable claiming in the dark.

This is a good time to force a claim.

Not exactly. How JP reacts is important. Right now, he hasn't been given enough time (in my opinion) to react. If we suddenly get 6 people jumping on the vote ready to lynch, I'm ditching my vote. If he NEVER shows up to defend himself, or shows up and goes "I'm not going to defend myself because you wont do it." That matters a lot on if I'm ready to lynch or not.

And that is fair. We have a lot of time, still, before the phase ends. Seven hours, I think.

I could believe that about the SK, not the mafia. The mafia generally knows who each other is and is told a theme if it's not inherently obvious. At worst a fakeclaim that would be considered neutral is what they would come up with. And I agree with Aranatta. The pressure started right after he had participated pretty well, he likely hasn't seen the pressure.

I also don't entirely agree with the pressure. I respect both Rokk's position and justp's in regards to RP. I tend to favor justP's reasoning right now since the mafia should still be at high strength. If the mafia had a CMD, odds are high that they still have it. If we were mid-game, I would roll the dice and leave RP alive which would be more akin to Rokk's reasoning.

Not trying to actually defend justp, but I don't like the reasons for the pressure and I think if it came down to a lynch if he says nothing, I don't like it.

By the way gfish, did you have a good night?