In a normal HCRealms game, this is goodish. Better than average.

In a game with a time limit where giving up lynches is extra punishing and lynching townies is not as punishing, I think this is a bad result.

We need to lynch someone and we're choosing not to.

Additionally, only one of the five players with votes on them has defended himself and not enough to forgo a lynch, imo. Two further players were voted for and did successfully defend themselves.

Change vote Immortal Raven, mostly for having votes but also for promoting anti town behavior. /half cheeky

I'm actually looking for a replacement for I_R. In the past, I always just included him because we had sort of a reciprocal auto sign.

He's too busy right now so I'm looking for a replacement.

I'm somewhat reminded of the 100 Bullets game you ran where you outright said it was in the Town's interest to lynch as often as possible... and the Mafia won the only way they could, by running out the clock since the Town didn't listen.

By the way:

This, I assume, means that there will be another forum for the Upsidedown.

Also, it appears that we will have about 6 nights, if a) the Demigorgon is successful each night and b) nothing else draws/shoves somebody into the Upsidedown.

^^^ That should not be assumed to be accurate or a safe understanding. Just my baseline.

I assumed that too. There may even be four different upsidedown forums, considering the Demogorgon can shut one of the four down.

Depends a bit on how the Demogorgon decides to play this, I think. The safe play is to pull someone into the upsidedown one night, then kill them the next. However, a more risky play is to just keep pulling people into the upsidedown and wait for the throat slugs to kill them. That is potentially faster, but also more risky for the Demogorgon.

Ah, in that case.

remove vote

change vote: Immortal_Raven
I think a lynch is better than no lynch in this situation, and we may as well spare gfish the trouble of looking for a replacement. :D

Heading to bed now by the way, won't be around for the rest of the phase. See you tomorrow.

This bothers me. What if it's a pretty vital town role?

I was thinking the same thing.


@Ignatz: Nothing personal at all. Not to rehash the logic that's been stated over the course of over fifteen pages, but I was just looking for information and today has seemed fairly productive...I think?


Remove Vote

Yeah, not really digging that at all. Gfish said that he was already looking for a replacement.