Not lynching your top suspect just because they're maybe being replaced is a bad idea.

Not lynching the one player almost everyone has stated an opinion on, half pro and half against, is a bad idea.

Not lynching today is a bad idea.

Trying to switch to a new train is....par for the course but unlikely to succeed.

I'd claim something, if I were you. You're about tied with IR I believe.

And Jack, why is IR our top suspect? TSP has pinged me more with his posting than IR, who's basically said "meh ain't really here" and is presumably getting replaced. That's a scum tell now?

1) He's not trying to play as town

2) He happened to be the player closest to being able to get any lynch at all.

3) He voted no lynch

4) Several players had immediate negative reaction to his lynch train

That's my thing. I actually think TSP (considering his unwillingness to acknowledge the pressure while he's here) is waving a red flag more than IR at this point.

I actually agree with this however I'm attempting to play reckless as I sometimes am prone to do in this game

#1, can you elaborate?

#4 would suggest he's mafia, not the Demigorgon, so that's not really an imperative the same way, right?

#3 I don't see an issue with, as I don't agree with the premise that any lynch > no lynch, but we've been over that.

oh fer....gotta love typing from a phone. I meant to say I'm trying to NOT play reckless. geez...

Oh I agree, but not from anyone claiming under pressure, since nobody has claimed.

I am acknowledging the pressure, but I don't know how to do more than that.

A name would be good.

I thought people were voting IR because we "need a lynch!" and he doesn't seem to want to play. Not because he seemed scummy. I switched to someone who I actually want info on that someone else was willing to vote for, since they didn't go for my original switch to (KJ).

A lot of the weird stuff hapened because gfish said he was looking for a replacement.

1) He's expressed no interest in participating, yet placed a vote. You can actually win as mafia like this. It hinders the town. Apathy always hinders the town. I'm not saying this is a problem on a personal level and I understand the replacement requestbut there's no protown action here.

4) Yes.

Chance if fakeclaims being provided for scum: High
Chance of an extension due to replacement: Medium low

Agreed. change vote: TSP

Precisely. I even stated that as my reason for switching.