You are currently viewing HCRealms.com, The Premier HeroClix Community, as a Guest. If you would like to participate in the community, please Register to join the discussion!
If you are having problems registering to an account, feel free to Contact Us.
Oh I am not going after you your reasonings. You put together a well thought out vote - I don't agree with it, but I find your reasoning consistent with your vote.
I don't with Gfish.
But I am more concerned with JoH right now.
I think you're reading too much into the lack of a vote whereas I may be reading too much in to Darkstone's diction and word choice.
Capt was random pressure as far as I can see and viciousbuddha pressure was pretty weak.
I tried to go after colonial due to reasoning that they wasted a powerful ability and got derailed. Admittedly it was conjecture and I switched in the interest of getting something done, but it got dismissed. Now I come with another line of reasoning and you wait until after I throw down votes to switch the pressure again. Can't say it sits well with me at all regardless of your reasoning.
I will also point out that lots of random pressure in an All Stars game is very dangerous. I mean, a role claim is a power claim. Because all roles are available for all to see. And I don't really want to give the mafia too much of a road map on Day 2.
I think you're reading too much into the lack of a vote whereas I may be reading too much in to Darkstone's diction and word choice.
Capt was random pressure as far as I can see and viciousbuddha pressure was pretty weak.
I tried to go after colonial due to reasoning that they wasted a powerful ability and got derailed. Admittedly it was conjecture and I switched in the interest of getting something done, but it got dismissed. Now I come with another line of reasoning and you wait until after I throw down votes to switch the pressure again. Can't say it sits well with me at all regardless of your reasoning.
Actually - if you look at my train of thought....
Quote : Originally Posted by MSU
I am actually interested in the people who didn't throw down votes now.
^^^ came before....
Quote : Originally Posted by Immortal_Raven
change vote: Darkstone
Anyone find this post scummy, because I do. Show up, vote, and then read the thread. At best it's sloppy and at worst it's scummy with a "but I was just pressuring" excuse.
Sorry for my evening absence, twas boardgame night.
Quote : Originally Posted by MSU
JoH and Magnito never voted before the claim.
Townies vote for whatever. Scum don't vote because they don't want to leave a paper trail.
It bothers me.
^^^then I went back and searched for the people who didn't throw down a vote, found out that Magnito and JoH stood out, and hence I brought it up.
So technically, I was already in the mind set and doing thread diving (see my first post of the morning) before you posted your Darkstone theory.
#justsaying
Quote : Originally Posted by Old Lady from JLU "Patriot Act" to the General
You think killing Superman would make the world safe? Or killing this boy? Or killing us? Tell me, how many of us do you have to kill to keep us safe?
Quote : Originally Posted by Loki from "The Avengers" to Thor
Your initial post came 1 minute before and I didn't see it before I started responding to the thread. Time stamps matter. Nice try.
You did follow up, but here's the part that bugs me. There was a mass-RB and only one non-scum power went off that we know of. It's all conjecture at this point and you still waited a full hour after my vote and your observation about JoH and Mags to actually vote for one of them.
If you vote right away, it's not a big deal. But waiting until the train gets traction for what you said yourself was cohesive reasoning even if you didn't agree with it and then starting your other train just does not sit well with me.
Me, at 8:52 am waking up and getting to the thread...
then, as I was going through the thread, I made my post about people not voting. As it stood out to me.
Then, after getting through some IRL work, I posted that the two people who stood out to me were Mags and JoH
Quote : Originally Posted by Immortal_Raven
Your initial post came 1 minute before and I didn't see it before I started responding to the thread. Time stamps matter. Nice try.
You did follow up, but here's the part that bugs me. There was a mass-RB and only one non-scum power went off that we know of. It's all conjecture at this point and you still waited a full hour after my vote and your observation about JoH and Mags to actually vote for one of them.
If you vote right away, it's not a big deal. But waiting until the train gets traction for what you said yourself was cohesive reasoning even if you didn't agree with it and then starting your other train just does not sit well with me.
You are trying to be me when I am scum by twisting things around to your own thoughts that support your line of thinking.
So I will reiterate one more time - My thought process was detailed in my first post, as I was going thread diving to look for anything that stood out.
As I was reading the thread, I posted that what stood out to me were the people not voting.
Then I decided to go one step further and mention who I thought were the ones that stood out to me.
I don't care about your vote on Darkstone because I think it's a bad/going no where lead at this moment in the game.
I care about my vote and reasoning on JoH and it looks like other agree.
Quote : Originally Posted by Old Lady from JLU "Patriot Act" to the General
You think killing Superman would make the world safe? Or killing this boy? Or killing us? Tell me, how many of us do you have to kill to keep us safe?
Quote : Originally Posted by Loki from "The Avengers" to Thor
I am heading to work. I will not be back before the thread closes. I would rather not be lynched while I am gone, but not much I can do to stop you. If you do, that's your prerogative.
Townies vote for whatever. Scum don't vote because they don't want to leave a paper trail.
It bothers me.
Oh yeah?
Is that how I've ever acted as scum? I hold back and don't vote?
That's funny that you think that because the last game we played together and I was scum, I lead a lynch train on you. So I think this little story of how my not voting makes you think I'm suspicious is a lie. I don't think you think that at all. Why would you? Makes me think you're scum, MSU.
As for why I didn't throw down a vote, it was a pressure vote and I'm traveling this weekend and there were plenty of votes already and nobody being voted for was particularly pinging me. So why add a useless vote that I don't mean and that I won't be able to take back?
... remove vote
This arguing is doing two things;
1) making me unsure what the heck I'm doing and while I think a no lynch is not a good option.. It's becoming appealing.
2) it is also really explaining why my spider sense tingles when MSU speak X_X
Rokk_Krinn- "Telling the truth and sticking by it always looks clumsier because it's not a pre-planned malice."
Is that how I've ever acted as scum? I hold back and don't vote?
That's funny that you think that because the last game we played together and I was scum, I lead a lynch train on you. So I think this little story of how my not voting makes you think I'm suspicious is a lie. I don't think you think that at all. Why would you? Makes me think you're scum, MSU.
As for why I didn't throw down a vote, it was a pressure vote and I'm traveling this weekend and there were plenty of votes already and nobody being voted for was particularly pinging me. So why add a useless vote that I don't mean and that I won't be able to take back?
What on earth are you talking about??? I am the ONE player that leaves the baggage in the other game. For crying out loud...get off the cross JoH, someone needs the wood.
Second, you never stated why you aren't throwing a vote down. you joke voted and left.
In the game of mafia, yes, that qualified as suspicious.
Quote : Originally Posted by Old Lady from JLU "Patriot Act" to the General
You think killing Superman would make the world safe? Or killing this boy? Or killing us? Tell me, how many of us do you have to kill to keep us safe?
Quote : Originally Posted by Loki from "The Avengers" to Thor