I'd like to nominate the SF Human Torch...he's nuts in an evasion deck.

cmac, remember this is just DC... he's not a valid candidate... but he's really BROKEN in that deck... he's the same Bastion is for CS... but much more better....

<Sarcasm> Oh, is this DC only...</SAR....nah I'll just leave that one open for later>

I cant believe you left 5 drop Hal Jordan off the list he is so important in my one character on the board at a time deck where he is a 12 12 those stats are too good plus he is a rare so he is super valueable a guy at my shop gave me one for a savage beatdown and fizzle... sucker

Wow, GL is totally undermining the X-Statix mechanic. That's not cool. We should ban all Green Latern cards. And make Knightfall. And make another awesome 5 drop Batman so he could be on this list.

5
Batman<>Better than Garth
GK/TT
When Batman stuns a character, that character's controller lose endurance equal to that character's cost.
Pay 3 ENd--> Return a card from your KOed pile to your hand. Use this ability only once per turn.

Flavor text not required.

cmac: A little more balanced plz, and stats.

Here's my rework of your card.

5
10/11
Batman<>Better than Garth
GK/TT/JLA (Make it fit)
Flight Range Concealed Optional
When a Gotham Knights character stuns a character, that character's controller loses endurance equal to characters cost.
Pay 3 Endurance -->Return up to 2 cards from your KO pile to your hand. Use this power only once per turn
Exhaust a Gotham Knights character-->Negate payment power effect

Im not sure whether to give him loyalty or not.

I think the negate ability should only require a discard, not an exhaustion. You're version wouldn't quite make MY top 5, as arbitrary as it may be...and do you think maybe he should be an army character with a boost?

Why don't you guys give Batman his props!?

That version of Batman should be at LEAST 7 drop level. As I said before, I think drawing cards is overrated. I mean, look at any miniatures games - you don't see THEM drawing cards do you?

I think that Batman's power should be:
Make Your Opponent Pay 1 Endurance: Stun Target Character with a cost less than Batman

What game are you playing?

Bizarro System. Which is why Bizarro should be number 1, not the Manhunter. He's nowhere near as good as underdropping Spoiler (1) on 5 though.... that's gg right there.

What game am I playing, Goop? Why, I'm insulted. I'm playing Vs. System. It seems, however, that you have no concept of the Metagame at the moment. I'll bet people in your area aren't even PLAYING the great Xavier's Dream/Rigged Elections combo deck with Alfred, are they?

Five copies of Intergang on turn 5 for the all ongoing plot twist resource row Revenge Squad deck ... if you don't have Toy Soliders, than it's good game right there. If you have played Toy Soliders, you might be in for some trouble though.

How about this....
Snoop Dogg<>Tha Rizzle Dizzle
GK
9/9, F/R
Pay 1 END--->Counter target PT effect.
Pay 1 END--->Replace target Ongoing PT
Fizzle my nizzle, get yo' shizzle outtha hizzle.

<Sarcasm Again> That card sucks!!! Why would anyone like a card that you just pay a little endurance and gives you a pretty nice abillity??? it is so much like Garth and Garth is bad!!! It will never make a top 10 characters List.... *Keeps getting bitter* </Sarcasm Again>

<S>As I stated before, this is my list and its arbitrary. You're entitled to clog up the board with your own equally inane list, but these are my opinions, foundationless though they may be...</S>