NA Superman, Last Son of Krypton
0 Superman-Batman Robot
1 Lady Blackhawk
2 Quicksilver
3 Barbara Gordon <> Oracle, Hacker Elite
4 Wonder Woman, Avatar of Peace
5 Black Manta
6 Beast Boy, Freak of Nature
7 Silver Surfer, The Last Zenn-Lavian
8 The Sleeper, Doomsday Device * RAID
9 Tenebruous
10 Imperiex
11 Silver Surfer

Stu,
When does the voting on this end? I only ask because there are going to be a few more preview cards coming down the pike so some of these votes may change, especially after Friday :)

This IS the voting.

- Superman; no contest.
0 - Haywire; The only other possibility is batman/superman robot. Haywire is more combo-friendly.
1 - Dagger, Child of Light - searched out by wild ride, can find midnight sons, can bounce to hand? Yes please. She is the lynchpin of the midnight sons engine; how many other 1-drops are as well integrated into an engine as her?
2 - Quicksilver - proven himself in many top tier decks. no competition.
3 - Ahmed - same.
4 - Dr. Doom - same.
5 - Garth - that secret society guy has nothing on the classic.
6 - Bastion - He ran riot for nearly an entire YEAR! If that doesn't merit him a spot on the curve of death, then the curve of death shouldn't run a 6-drop.
7 - Spider-Man, TASM - YES! My fav. card ever, 3rd time running champion please.
8 - Silver Surfer - the fan4 surfer did wonders in MSM, and I was glad to see him reprinted. he basically says GG.
9 - Galactus - autowin
10 - Stardust - what stardust has over imperidex is stardust triggers INSTANTANEOUSLY. impi waits till combat. sure, both still are endgamers, but idk. I guess I want to see some fresh blood.
11 - Silver Surfer - never losing is pretty good I hear (oh and no competition to boot.)

edit: if banned cards are allowed, I'm changing ahmed to Dr. Light.

Ahmed is light years ahead Babs. Light years.

- Superman
0 - Superman-Batman Robot
1 - Mr.Mxyzptlk
2 - Poison Ivy
3 - Barbara Gordon
4 - Dr. Doom
5 - Garth
6 - Batman Cape and Cowl
7 - Silver Surfer (MEX)
8 - Captain Marvel
9 - Galactus
10 - Stardust (does Stardust target your opponent if you only play against 1 person? if so, then stardust otherwise Imperiex
11 - Silver Surfer

yea i would like to know a star dust ruling in a 1 on 1 game

Here's the card text for Stardust, Herald

When Stardust enters play, target opponent chooses a player friendly to him. The chosen player KO's all characters he controls.

In a 1 on 1 game, target opponent chooses a player friendly to him. His only choice should be himself.

Don't quote me on this though... Will be better if HC speaks his holy words.

N/A-We all know there is only one--Superman Last Son of Krypton
0. Quicksilver
1. Moloids
2. Leech
3. It really depends, if we are talking all cards ever made, Dr. Light MoH. If not, DC Origins Arsenal.
4. Wonder Woman, AoP
5. Marrow
6. Batman Cape and Cowl
7. Beta Ray Bill. There! I said it! Love his ability way too much.
8. Hulk, World Breaker. Combined with Rightous Fury, your opponent's field is gone during the beginning of combat, meaning their field is gone and they are taking at least 20 to the face.
9. Galactus
10. Death
11. Silver Surfer

I will divide mine into GA/SA/MA (post MUN) if thats ok but if not then go with the golden picks

0- Amelia Voght/ Aunt May/ Superman/Batman robot
1- Riddler/ Riddler/ Riddler
2-Poison Ivy/ Quicksilver/ Luke Cage
3- Dr. Doom /Ahmed/ Batman-FM
4- Dr. Doom/ Divinity/Wonder Woman aop
5- Garth/ Black Manta/ Black Manta
6- Gorilla Grodd/ The Joker-Crazy For You/ Batman Cape and Cowl
7- Two-Face/ Silver Surfer-LZN /Superman-DF
8- Captain Marvel/ Bat-Mite/ Bat-Mite
9- Anti-monitor/ Galactus/ Superman
10-Mageddon/ Imperiex/ Imperiex

Non-characters
0-Utility Belt/ Ego-Gem/ Certifiable
1-Rigged Elections/ Beside Myself/ Beside Myself
2-Straight To The Grave/ Money Talks/ Only Human
3-Cosmic Radiation/ Mobilize/ Force Field Projection
4-Reign of Terror/ Path. Attempt/ Path. Attmept

0 - Superman/Batman Robot
1 - Valeria Von Doom
2 - Terra
3 -
4 - Diabolic Genius
5 -
6 - Deathstroke, Killing Machine
7 - Kara Zor-El ¤ Supergirl
8 - Ultra-Humanite
9 - Galactus
10 - Imperiex

shoot gotta get to work...going to have to come back to this later!

No Cost - The One and Only
0 Cost - Superman/Batman Robot
1 cost - Riddler
2 cost - Quicksilver
3 cost - Barbara Gordon <> Oracle
4 cost - Wonder Woman, Avatar of Peace
5 cost - Black Manta
6 cost - Batman, Cape and Cowl
7 cost - Spiderman, the Amazing Spider-Man (I'm going to break with the "relevance" theme because he's just plan amazing)
8 cost - Darkseid
9 cost - Galactus
10 - Imperiex
And this one goes all the way to eleven
11 - The Silver Surfer

Hmmm, is MU legal? I mean, we've never seen it in action, so it's tough to say...

Anyway, a vote:

0 drop: Superman Robot (beats out Haywire)
1 drop: Lady BlackHawk - Tutor effects are awesome, and tutor effects that come with a 2/1 concealed character are even better. That she also has substitute (making her a non-dead draw later) makes her better than Alfred/Boris (the old stand-bys)
2 drop: Quicksilver. Never has a 2-drop needed to be banned as badly as this guy.
3 drop:Ahmed. 6/6, concealed, and a deck-defining ability. This guy is amazing, especially with the lack. I'm assuming Dr. Light being banned DQs him.
4 drop: Punisher 4-drop. He's the legend to beat at this point, amazing effect that can win games on his own.
5 drop: Black Mantis. He's like Garth on a team that can use him better, and without the gayness of being Aquaman's prodigy. Though he is Aquaman's brother...
6 drop: Batman <> Cape and Cowl. Yay, a Batman makes the list :).
7 drop: I'd say Spidey <> AS is probably still the best overall, but he never sees play (lack of a good team). So I'm giving my power to Superman 7-drop, mostly because he's a solid stall character on a solid stall team; great stats and great off-init power, which are the things you look for in a 7-drop.
8 drop: Sentry... this guy is worth trying to get online. 8 drop Hulk from MU does look promising though...
9 drop: Onslaught. I still think he's better than Galactus 9-drop
10 drop: Imperix. Only one that has seen top 8 in a major tourney.
11 drop/No drop go to their defaults.

No cost = Superman, LSoK

0 = Haywire

1 = Lockjaw __Hon mention: Longshot

2 = Quicksilver

3 = Ahmed

4 = Fatality __Hon mention: Punisher, Guns Blazing & Spider-Man, TSSM

5 = Black Manta __Hon mention: Garth (sooo many choices at 5)

6 = Terrax __Hon mention: Wonder Man & The Joker, Crazy For You

7 = Spider-Man, Stark's Protoge

8 = The Sentry __Hon mention: Psycho Pirate

9 = Galactus

10= Imperiex

11 = Silver Surfer

Edit: If we go with any timeframe before ruling & errata changes (not bannings), then Bizarro gets the #4 slot with an honorable mention to Dvinity.

No Cost) Superman, Last Son of Krypton
0) Superman/Batman Robot, Supa-Mecha-Bat
1) The Riddler, Riddle Me This
2) Black Cat, Nine Lives
3) Barbara Gordon <> Oracle, Hacker Elite
4) Wonder Woman, Avatar of Peace
5) Superman, Metropolis Marvel
6) Holocaust, Nemesis
7) Punisher, Angel of Death
8) Silver Surfer, Norrin Radd
9) Galactus, Devourer of Worlds
10) Imperiex, The Beginning and the End
11) Silver Surfer, Herald


In my opinion, Imperiex is a better 10 due to the fact that you could bring him out on 9...which would be a full round before Stardust's power would trigger from recruit.