You had Vivian from the first season of AHS.
(I’ll never forget how much I enjoyed the role and the irony of it. :D )

*ahem*

I don't see Anonymous listed.

*ahem*

Do we need an anonymous yet? Are people already feeling picked on?

Any theme could be anonymous. If people want, I'd do it. I love anonymous games. Always a lot if fun.

There have been some requests for anonymous in the Wednesday game nights. That being said, I'm most interested in a TV reboot or SSBU. I also do care about Arkham and Hastur and The King in Yellow are some of my favorite parts of the mythos, but I'd like to see a TV mafia first.

TV is a series. So if rather keep that seperate from anonymous.

I could do Smash Bros as anonymous though, if people are interested.

It's played on a proboards. A assign everyone a generic name and no one reveals who they are.

Nicknames are themed. I've used colours, countries, elements, fruits, flowers and alcohol in past games.

So you play Mafia with the same people, but identities are hidden. That way, all grudges and preconceptions get left behind because you don't actually know who anyone is.

.

I'm personally not a fan of the anonymous setup. Mainly because my play style is so unique that people can guess right away who I am anyway.

My big issue with the Arkham games is that they feel like they sacrifice game for theme. In order for the Big Bad to feel like a proper horror, they have to be crazy powerful (or at least unkillable). But that makes the game unbalanced. It becomes an authentic Arkham experience, but loses the thread of what a mafia game is about.

I enjoyed the tone and powers of the previous games, but the looming unkillable baddy spoils things for me.

If I run Arkham 3, it's a problem I intend to address.

Anonymous games are a good chance to experiment. You don't have to be boxed in by people's expectations.

I think part of the reason I’m not fond of anonymous games is because I like taking those pre-conceived notions about me and using them against people.

In all seriousness, I vote for #2.

If only so I have the chance to ####ing kill Kirby and Meta Knight.

My children are seriously pissing me off with how much they beat me with them.

Who are you playing as, Little Mac? Kirby is terrible, no offense intended.

I think I've settled on Smash as the theme. The real question is anonymous or not