I'd at least expect more information as to what he found, and hoped to find. Ignatz was at the very least cleared by someone we all thought was the cop.

Granted Don cloaks always can come into play here, but one of the cardinal rules of mafia is trust the cop until you are given reason not to do so.

Right, why also were you info gathering after I was copped?

Let's close this out, folks.

All this discussion is fascinating. You have convinced me that ice is not likely on the up-and-up, but guys ERS is neither dead nor alive . . . why does this not concern you all?

It does concern me, but typically when someone is "undead" there are contingencies to their death. Regardless, we know of ERS so he's easier to minimize.

I see no reason not to lynch ERS again until it sticks. One lynched survival does not make lynch immunity.

vote EnsRedShirt, although I would like some pressure elsewhere.

Oh there are concerns, but we still need to shake the trees so to speak and find out what falls out.

We have perfectly good pressure on Ice, gfish.

Rokk has something-- he apparently targeted Destructo last night.

Ice claims he targeted me with some sort of info gathering. Which makes little sense, since I started up on ERS out of thin air on a hunch and apparently struck paydirt *and* I have been copped as town.

He also didn't bring this up until he was under the gun.

I haven't seen a clearer lynch target in some while-- while ERS may be immune until he's solo and we may waste another day.

Clarify-- Rokk say Ice targeted Destructo.

Vote Count

Iceman: Roy, Ignatz
ERS: Nifty, gfish

Majority is 6. 9.5 hours remain.

I will switch for now, but I would seriously like to take another crack at EnsRedShirt. He may be immune, but more likely just has an extra life.

Immunity rarely ends the phase - normally it does not. We ended the phase when we lynched EnsRedShirt.

vote Iceman for now; although throwing a vote on scum does not mean that you are not scum, just that you are likely not on each other's faction.

vote: Ice

I'm fairly convinced and since ERS may or may not have protections beyond an extra life, I'm willing to lynch Ice.

Why can't Ice be taken out by the vig?

Can the vig even target someone who's not on the active player list?

The vig can target whomever they like (as long as it isn't me). Why are you so against this Ice lynch?

Even if he could be, I am more convinced of Ice's scumminess than ERS's at this point. granted, I have them both in the high-90s.

I was copped town, and turned up ERS.
Ice decides to info-gather on me, he claims? And only after pressured.
And Rokk RT-ed him to the dead cop.

Seems pretty-open-and-shut to me, while lynching ENS could *maybe* be wasting a day.

I'd rather go for the surer thing.