Maybe the theme is just in general "Violent Santa's"

Violence seems to be a theme, if not Santa.

Which is why I could see Making Christmas as neutral (not really "violent"... but they ARE monsters... and Jack thinks he's Santa more or less)

change vote: silver

Don't feel great about it, but it is what it is at this point.

If the theme is violent/deadly Santas, then vlad might well be Grandma Got Run Over by a Reindeer and not Sleigh Ride.

Would be a suitable song for a mafia busdriver.

Day 4 vote count:

Silver Lantern: Afrcngy, DestructoBoy, RenegadeRoy
RenegadeRoy: Ignatz_Mouse, Silver Lantern
Ignatz_Mouse: RenegadeRoy, Truffle Shuffle

With 8 players, 5 is majority. No majority was reached.

Tension was high in the town. There was a frantic rush around the Christmas tree with everyone trying to point fingers at others. This kept up for a while, and then suddenly it was night again.

Night 4 begins now! You have 24 hours to submit your actions.

The pale man was walking down a street when he saw someone else approaching from the other end of the street. When the two came face to face, they looked at each other closely, then nodded in agreement as they realized they were both out in the same business. Together, they walked up to someone's front door, opened it, and stepped in. They saw the clear-eyed woman sitting by a roaring fire, busy knitting something. She barely looked up when they entered.
"I figured you might come." she said. "I suppose I should be honored that you both decided to visit me though." The woman put the knitting down.
"There, I suppose it is as done as it will ever be. I should tell you your endeavor is fruitless though. As long as there is goodness in mans' hearts, evil will never prevail. Shall we begin?"
What followed was horrible beyond description. When it was over the assailants couldn't help but feel disappointed - the clear-eyed woman hadn't screamed even once, she had met her ultimate fate with her dignity preserved.

Truffle Shuffle is dead. She was God Rest Ye Merry Gentlemen, the mod's wife's favorite Christmas song. She was Town.



Day 5 begins now! You have 24 hours to get something done!

With 7 players, 4 is majority.

BD targets from last night, Vlad?

Hmm. Both killers had the same target. Interesting. Do we think the pale man is mafia or the SK?

Not really interesting, it makes sense they both wanted to take out the doc.

What did you learn last night, Dboy?

There's two mafia and the SK left. We need to lynch one today or we're in big trouble.

Roy, what are your reads on the remaining players?

What did you learn, Silver?

1. DestructoBoy -- random info, It's Beginning to Look a Lot Like Christmas
5. Fredwood -- magnet, The Christmas Song
7. Silver Lantern -- oracle, I want a Hippo for Christmas
9. Afrcngy -- tracker, I Saw Mommy Kissing Santa Claus
12. Ignatz_Mouse -- blocker, Fairytale of new York
13. vlad3theimpaler -- busdriver, Sleigh Ride
14. RenegadeRoy -- cop, That's Christmas to Me

Roy, what did you learn? Even confirming a townie would be a huge win right now.

I learned that Roy is not neutral last night, so that rules him out as the SK.

You might have been onto something with the Grandma got run over by a reindeer thing.

Who did you block Iggy? Unless there's a strategic reason not to reveal that at this time. That could clear someone of not being a killer, absent an unblockable kill.