You are currently viewing HCRealms.com, The Premier HeroClix Community, as a Guest. If you would like to participate in the community, please Register to join the discussion!
If you are having problems registering to an account, feel free to Contact Us.
Must have missed where you said you were the killer.
This is hilarious! Good show, Linkor.
Quote : Originally Posted by CaptainNifty
I certainly didn't say "always."
They tend to act a certain way.
I still love generalizing. Like drive by posting is always trust worthy.
Quote : Originally Posted by PhoenixFire
This should have been said at the start of the day.
Said with some backing, I completely agree. Information was provided for ONE possible mafia member, by somebody, who by own admission, hasn't be active on posting.
This should have been said at the start of the day.
Nobody challenged me on how I would know this. I simply said, "grizz killed SL."
Nobody asked how I knew. You just listened to grizz talk about failing to doctor the cop. And then followed his lead.
You didn't need SL to say he was the cop, why do you need me to give details. The more details a townie gives unprompted the more powerful the mafia is.
Commissioner of Heroclix Fantasy League - Ask me about it!
HCFL:
Follow me on Twitter @PopofHeroes
Said with some backing, I completely agree. Information was provided for ONE possible mafia member, by somebody, who by own admission, hasn't be active on posting.
You want additional info, ask.
You should know what my power is by now, and if you don't pay attention. I'm not going to draw a map for the mafia. They know too much already. Town needs to do better at investigating, and stop telling people who provide information they need to prove how they got their information to be credible. You have information that is different you should refute it.
Right now the arguments are as follows:
Nifty: I know grizz killed SL.
Grizz: Nope, I'm the doctor who didn't protect the cop.
Everybody else: Yeah, grizz bad move that you didn't doctor the cop. I completely buy that you are three characters even though everyone else is just 2. Let's vote for TB.
Commissioner of Heroclix Fantasy League - Ask me about it!
HCFL:
Follow me on Twitter @PopofHeroes
Said with some backing, I completely agree. Information was provided for ONE possible mafia member, by somebody, who by own admission, hasn't be active on posting.
Exactly, they'd have to tell us a bit more than someone killed someone else. To me it was a flared up post to place a vote on Grizz since he didn't mention anything afterwards.
Quote : Originally Posted by CaptainNifty
Nobody challenged me on how I would know this. I simply said, "grizz killed SL."
Nobody asked how I knew. You just listened to grizz talk about failing to doctor the cop. And then followed his lead.
You didn't need SL to say he was the cop, why do you need me to give details. The more details a townie gives unprompted the more powerful the mafia is.
Silver was the reason Adam was hung on day 2. The town didn't need anything else from him at that point.
We would have needed more from you considering you said Bob wasn't taking actions then mentioned you misread and he was taking actions after-all. I agree with you that the town shouldn't give out information freely, but we're at the end here. If you knew Grizz was the killer then it would be best to yell it out and make it known to all of us that he was the killer.
Exactly, they'd have to tell us a bit more than someone killed someone else. To me it was a flared up post to place a vote on Grizz since he didn't mention anything afterwards.
Silver was the reason Adam was hung on day 2. The town didn't need anything else from him at that point.
We would have needed more from you considering you said Bob wasn't taking actions then mentioned you misread and he was taking actions after-all. I agree with you that the town shouldn't give out information freely, but we're at the end here. If you knew Grizz was the killer then it would be best to yell it out and make it known to all of us that he was the killer.
I did yell it out. I just didn't say how I knew.
I will not apologize for "failing" to reveal the source of good information, when my information wasn't questioned by anyone other than the accused.
As to the Bob thing, I get what your saying, but that actually should get to my credibility as a townie since my mistake covered for non-scum without any prompting. I'm clearly not scum, so I should be trusted over a complete unknown.
Commissioner of Heroclix Fantasy League - Ask me about it!
HCFL:
Follow me on Twitter @PopofHeroes
Everybody else: Yeah, grizz bad move that you didn't doctor the cop. I completely buy that you are three characters even though everyone else is just 2. Let's vote for TB.
Everybody else including YOU.
Quote : Originally Posted by CaptainNifty
Well, that was stupid.
SL was the cop, and you didn't target him. You knew he was a townie, but you went with PF because you thought he seemed townie.
I don't even know what to do with that.
Also, what made PF more townie than me?
Rather than say, Hey I know you killed Silver, the jig is up, you instead focus on the folly that was his decision to doctor me and then ask why PF is considered more townie than you are.