One problem we are having is that three people claim a different source of the kills.

Morph claims one was Quebbster.

Truffle claims one was Grizzz.

Silver Lantern claims one was his.

There were three kills.

Vote Count:

grizzz (4): Truffles, Immortal_Raven, Colonialbob, gfish

Silver Lantern (1): grizzz

Truffle Shuffle (1): JoH

Rokk’s vote is with Iceman

With 16 players, 9 is a majority

No real changes in the past 6-7 pages AFAIK, but reposting it for reference.

I figured morph was misdirected.

TWO KILLS! I mean there were two kills.

Vote Silver Lantern

I asked you a question.

Thought I'd be okay with the theme, but yeah. The only character I recognize is Garrus.

So the first part of the write-up was a foiled kill...Garrus takes out Pax and The Grizzz is implicated in taking out the Capt.

I was trying to come up with a scenario where a "pusher" would cause the cause the crazy night, but can't see a plausible explanation where that would work. "Shape-shifter" could account for that. And not coming to the defense of the Grizzz, but there could have also been a "copping" of his character on a previous night and a "ghostwrite" as his character making the kill.

That first part isn't a foiled attempt?

Vote Count:

grizzz (4): Truffles, Immortal_Raven, Colonialbob, gfish

Silver Lantern (3): grizzz, Ice+Rokk

Truffle Shuffle (1): JoH

Rokk’s vote is with Iceman

With 16 players, 9 is a majority

Not sure what a scanners meme is, but this seems fitting.

I don't think pusher works to explain my results. And I don't think that's a ghost write of Sophia Hawked as the being doing the killing is described as inhuman. Doesn't fit.

Head blowing up due to psychic energy from the David Cronenberg movie. Google at your own risk.

Something's not jiving here with me.

Agreed with the pusher - just doesn't work in any scenario.

vote grizz

I thought I'd done that earlier.

Feel like we are getting overly tied down with possible complexity scenarios as opposed to keeping to basics.

For example, Ice has an issue with SL. SL is claiming to be the Vig and freely admits to killing Pax. That would seem to be a case of either we let the real Vig sort out SL - if he's fibbing - or we wait and see what happens but not lynching SL (claiming Vig) is probably a good course.
(Related to this: SL was outted as Vig by Morph supposedly not reading the thread).

Then we have Grizzz and Truff. One of the two is fibbing based on the mod, surprisingly, giving away some information (not that I'm complaining; it's a nice change from having to wait until post-game to hear how a mod does things). Grizzz is Masoned with JoH but after recent games I could completely see Mal Mason a Town and non-Town so that point is a wash. Grizzz was claiming a power and when I said someone else had that he said he's the oft-cited Inventor. He also said he could create a three-person Romance, something the mod outright told me is not allowed when I asked for specifics on the Wedding Ring effect. Truff, meanwhile, appears to be an info-gatherer and barring reasons to feel she's wrong - beyond the JoH vouching - there are less holes in her story than Grizzz's. Lynching him seems a better course of action.

Once we start throwing out paranoia of shape shifting, pushing, etc it's basically sowing the seeds of dissent to not trust any info gathered. Until I see more evidence of those odder possibles, I can't allow them to taint or it becomes an oroborous of "What If?" Scenarios.

Lynch Grizzz as the Day is heading to wee hours and ending and I would hate to see it wasted because we were avoiding a lynch due to -too many- leads. We're drowning ourselves with an embarrassment of riches.