CP up AngleMan's Range

AngleMan Copcicles in Q-22, R-22, S-22, T-22, 3 barriers around Superman, takes a token and push clix

(DFD to Icicle, AST to Lex)

Cold puts up a barrier in U-14, V-15, W-16, X-16

Damage done will be MM... just not sure who yet, but only DawnStar can attack, I assume I can figure it out after without slowing you down much

TMNT99's Darkseid’s Society (Home)

1) R Angle Man (Icicle; 5/6) W-15@
2) U Lex Luthor* (2/5) X-14
* w/ Contingency Plan (1 Token)
3) R Killer Moth (Lex Corp Battlesuit; 3/4) W-14
4) R Gorilla Grodd
5) R Captain Cold X-13@
6) R Funky Flashman (Street Thug) X-15

Icicle: DFD [3]
Lex: AST [2]
Grodd: SA [1]

vs.

Superclone's Legion of Superheroes (Visitor)

1) R Superman 100 (5/7) J12 @@
[1 SA]
2) E Cosmic Boy 70 (6/6) I9
[2 AST]
3) R Batman 64 (5/6) W20 @@
[2 SA][1 KO]
4) E Dawnstar 60 (4/6) U23

HO: V-18, I-12
LO: V-19, F-11


Special Object: 23) Telephone Booth (LO) -- A character occupying the same squares as this object can be dealt 1 pushing damage as a free action. - O-10

BFC: Fearless Assault

Map: Xavier’s Mansion (Outdoor)

http://www.ianparmenter.com/hcutils/...y47&u4=x-93y90

Yes, but to be fair, given that it has to do with *your* rolls, it is somewhat inappropriate for you to decide what is right. Certainly your input should be put forward and considered, but in fairness to other players, even though you developed the system, it is a conflict of interest for you to decide what is and isn't a new stat point when it involves your figures.

It is unlikely you would do anything negative to affect the game, but players could perceive it. Having the commissioners decide gives the appearance of impartiality.

I understand that . Just like TKing out of range makes sense, just like MCing out of range makes sense, just like Incap for a push makes sense, just like a flying character carrying another character away makes sense. Your reasoning makes sense. My reasoning is thus:

Setting up a Barrier around a figure, in a way that prevents them from making an attack (against a flier on an indoor map, against a non flier). According to the rules, unless that was the only feasible attack available to the opposing team, this action doesn't grant a DFD.

Incapacitate, hitting a character, and adding a token, awards an SA, not a DFD, though it causes the opposing character to be unable to attack. No DFD is awarded.

This is the precedence. You're asking for option 1 above, using Barrier to prevent a single opposing figure from making an attack. That does not grant DFDs. I've gone from 'ok, sure, see what the League thinks', to 'No, it doesn't grant a DFD.'. If Dawnstar was the only available figure Clone had to attack with, then yeah, that's a DFD.

The Incapacitate aspect of 'Copsicles' is superfluous. The power being used is Barrier. Barrier, used in the manner that you are using it, does not grant DFDs.

Again, I get the logic behind it. I'm moderating to the best of my ability, using the rules that you developed for us. This is my interpretation of your rules. The rules for DFDs and Barrier are the way they are, as made by you. I see absolutely no reason that it should change, because it's a Barrier that's -more- effective than other Barriers.

#### ... its been my turn for 2 days.

Turn ??

1) Cosmic Boy to M18.
2) Dawnstar to N22.

Batman and Superman clear. Batman ups his own defense.

TMNT99's Darkseid’s Society (Home)

1) R Angle Man (Icicle; 5/6) W-15@
2) U Lex Luthor* (2/5) X-14
* w/ Contingency Plan (1 Token)
3) R Killer Moth (Lex Corp Battlesuit; 3/4) W-14
4) R Gorilla Grodd
5) R Captain Cold X-13@
6) R Funky Flashman (Street Thug) X-15

Icicle: DFD [3]
Lex: AST [2]
Grodd: SA [1]

vs.

Superclone's Legion of Superheroes (Visitor)

1) R Superman 100 (5/7) J12
[1 SA]
2) E Cosmic Boy 70 (6/6) M18 @
[2 AST]
3) R Batman 64 (5/6) W20
[2 SA][1 KO]
4) E Dawnstar 60 (4/6) N22 @

HO: V-18, I-12
LO: V-19, F-11


Special Object: 23) Telephone Booth (LO) -- A character occupying the same squares as this object can be dealt 1 pushing damage as a free action. - O-10

BFC: Fearless Assault

Map: Xavier’s Mansion (Outdoor)

http://www.ianparmenter.com/hcutils/...&u5=x-264y-107

DFD to Cold

Cold will push to toss the same barrier up, takes a clix

Add one to CP

Masterminding on a case per case basis

TMNT99's Darkseid’s Society (Home)

1) R Angle Man (Icicle; 5/6) W-15
2) U Lex Luthor* (2/5) X-14
* w/ Contingency Plan (2 Token)
3) R Killer Moth (Lex Corp Battlesuit; 3/4) W-14
4) R Gorilla Grodd
5) R Captain Cold (4/5) X-13@@
6) R Funky Flashman (Street Thug) X-15

Icicle: DFD [3]
Lex: AST [2]
Grodd: SA [1]
Cold: DFD [1]

vs.

Superclone's Legion of Superheroes (Visitor)

1) R Superman 100 (5/7) J12
[1 SA]
2) E Cosmic Boy 70 (6/6) M18 @
[2 AST]
3) R Batman 64 (5/6) W20
[2 SA][1 KO]
4) E Dawnstar 60 (4/6) N22 @

HO: V-18, I-12
LO: V-19, F-11


Special Object: 23) Telephone Booth (LO) -- A character occupying the same squares as this object can be dealt 1 pushing damage as a free action. - O-10

BFC: Fearless Assault

Map: Xavier’s Mansion (Outdoor)

http://www.ianparmenter.com/hcutils/...&u5=x-264y-107

1) Cosmic Boy reaches out to his maximum range and picks up Batman. He places Batman at U11.
2) Batman ups his damage to 3. He levels a batarang at Killer Moth and throws it. (6,2) for a hit on the DV 13 and the KO.
Free: Batman outwits Luthor's outwit.
3) Superman moves to V19 stands on the LO and picks up the HO at V18

TMNT99's Darkseid’s Society (Home)

1) R Angle Man (Icicle; 5/6) W-15
2) U Lex Luthor* (2/5) X-14
* w/ Contingency Plan (2 Token)
3) R Killer Moth (Lex Corp Battlesuit) KO
4) R Gorilla Grodd
5) R Captain Cold (4/5) X-13@@
6) R Funky Flashman (Street Thug) X-15

Icicle: DFD [3]
Lex: AST [2]
Grodd: SA [1]
Cold: DFD [1]

vs.

Superclone's Legion of Superheroes (Visitor)

1) R Superman 100 (5/7) V19 @
[1 SA]
2) E Cosmic Boy 70 (6/6) M18 @@
[3 AST]
3) R Batman 64 (5/6) U11 @
[3 SA][2 KO]
4) E Dawnstar 60 (4/6) N22

HO: I-12
LO: V-19, F-11


Special Object: 23) Telephone Booth (LO) -- A character occupying the same squares as this object can be dealt 1 pushing damage as a free action. - O-10

BFC: Fearless Assault

Map: Xavier’s Mansion (Outdoor)

http://www.ianparmenter.com/hcutils/...&u5=x-264y-107

AngleMan uses barrier again, U-17, V-18, W-19, W-20, Superman takes a token and a push clix.

(1 DFD to AngleMan)

Funky moves to W-14

+1 to CP

TMNT99's Darkseid’s Society (Home)

1) R Angle Man (Icicle; 5/6) W-15@
2) U Lex Luthor* (2/5) X-14
* w/ Contingency Plan (3 Token)
3) R Killer Moth (Lex Corp Battlesuit) KO
4) R Gorilla Grodd
5) R Captain Cold (4/5) X-13
6) R Funky Flashman (Street Thug) W-14@

Icicle: DFD [4]
Lex: AST [2]
Grodd: SA [1]
Cold: DFD [1]

vs.

Superclone's Legion of Superheroes (Visitor)

1) R Superman 100 (4/7) V19 @@
[1 SA]
2) E Cosmic Boy 70 (6/6) M18 @@
[3 AST]
3) R Batman 64 (5/6) U11 @
[3 SA][2 KO]
4) E Dawnstar 60 (4/6) N22

HO: I-12
LO: V-19, F-11


Special Object: 23) Telephone Booth (LO) -- A character occupying the same squares as this object can be dealt 1 pushing damage as a free action. - O-10

BFC: Fearless Assault

Map: Xavier’s Mansion (Outdoor)

http://www.ianparmenter.com/hcutils/...&u5=x-264y-107

Turn: 10A

1) Batman swings around to X16. Push for a click of damage.
Free: Batman outwits Mastermind on Luthor
2) Dawnstar flies down to W13 AV 9 on DV 12. (3,1) for a hit and 2 damage. Luthor is KO'd. Dawnstar, out of movement stays at W13.

Clear Superman and Cosmic Boy

TMNT99's Darkseid’s Society (Home)

1) R Angle Man (Icicle; 5/6) W-15@
2) U Lex Luthor* X-14 KO
3) R Killer Moth (Lex Corp Battlesuit) KO
4) R Gorilla Grodd KO
5) R Captain Cold (4/5) X-13
6) R Funky Flashman (Street Thug) W-14@

Icicle: DFD [4]
Lex: AST [2]
Grodd: SA [1]
Cold: DFD [1]

vs.

Superclone's Legion of Superheroes (Visitor)

1) R Superman 100 (4/7) V19
[1 SA]
2) E Cosmic Boy 70 (6/6) M18
[3 AST]
3) R Batman 64 (4/6) X16 @@
[3 SA][2 KO]
4) E Dawnstar 60 (4/6) W13 @
[1 SA][1 KO]

HO: I-12
LO: V-19, F-11


Special Object: 23) Telephone Booth (LO) -- A character occupying the same squares as this object can be dealt 1 pushing damage as a free action. - O-10

BFC: Fearless Assault

Map: Xavier’s Mansion (Outdoor)

http://www.ianparmenter.com/hcutils/...184&u4=x-34y-2

AngleMan puts up a barrier around DawnStar, takes a token and a push, AngleMan pushes

Cold vs DawnStar. Av8 vs dv15, need an 7, roll is 1+5 for 6, miss.

(1 DFD to Icicle)

AngleMan will MM to Funky.

TMNT99's Darkseid’s Society (Home)

1) R Angle Man (Icicle; 4/6) W-15@@
2) U Lex Luthor* X-14 KO
3) R Killer Moth (Lex Corp Battlesuit) KO
4) R Gorilla Grodd KO
5) R Captain Cold (4/5) X-13@
6) R Funky Flashman (Street Thug) W-14

Icicle: DFD [4]
Lex: AST [2]
Grodd: SA [1]
Cold: DFD [1]

vs.

Superclone's Legion of Superheroes (Visitor)

1) R Superman 100 (4/7) V19
[1 SA]
2) E Cosmic Boy 70 (6/6) M18
[3 AST]
3) R Batman 64 (4/6) X16 @@
[3 SA][2 KO]
4) E Dawnstar 60 (3/6) W13 @@
[1 SA][1 KO]

HO: I-12
LO: V-19, F-11


Special Object: 23) Telephone Booth (LO) -- A character occupying the same squares as this object can be dealt 1 pushing damage as a free action. - O-10

BFC: Fearless Assault

Map: Xavier’s Mansion (Outdoor)

http://www.ianparmenter.com/hcutils/...7&u4=x-327y239

Turn 11A:

1) Cosmic Boy moves to S17.
2) Superman uses his heat vision on Angle Man. AV 9 plus Quarry on DV 17. (2,2) for a miss. #### ... I rolled the PC theme for the Teen keyword, but I just realized that no one can take the token. Cosmic Boy was going to, but he already moved, and I just checked the rules and you can't give two tokens in one round. B'oh.

TMNT99's Darkseid’s Society (Home)

1) R Angle Man (Icicle; 4/6) W-15@@
2) U Lex Luthor* X-14 KO
3) R Killer Moth (Lex Corp Battlesuit) KO
4) R Gorilla Grodd KO
5) R Captain Cold (4/5) X-13@
6) R Funky Flashman (Street Thug) W-14

Icicle: DFD [4]
Lex: AST [2]
Grodd: SA [1]
Cold: DFD [1]

vs.

Superclone's Legion of Superheroes (Visitor)

1) R Superman 100 (4/7) V19 @
[1 SA]
2) E Cosmic Boy 70 (6/6) S17 @
[3 AST]
3) R Batman 64 (4/6) X16
[3 SA][2 KO]
4) E Dawnstar 60 (3/6) W13
[1 SA][1 KO]

HO: I-12
LO: V-19, F-11


Special Object: 23) Telephone Booth (LO) -- A character occupying the same squares as this object can be dealt 1 pushing damage as a free action. - O-10

BFC: Fearless Assault

Map: Xavier’s Mansion (Outdoor)

http://www.ianparmenter.com/hcutils/...1&u6=x-240y173

Funky tries to hit DawnStar. Av8 vs dv15, need a 7, roll is 5+2 for 7, that's 1 clix to DawnStar

(1 SA to Street Thug)

Cold will try to push and take down DawnStar. Av8 vs dv15, need a 7, roll is 6+4 for 10, 2 clix and the KO, 1 to Cold for the push.

(1 SA and 1 KO to Cold)

Continue to MM to Funky

TMNT99's Darkseid’s Society (Home)

1) R Angle Man (Icicle; 4/6) W-15
2) U Lex Luthor* X-14 KO
3) R Killer Moth (Lex Corp Battlesuit) KO
4) R Gorilla Grodd KO
5) R Captain Cold (3/5) X-13@@
6) R Funky Flashman (Street Thug) W-14@

Icicle: DFD [4]
Lex: AST [2]
Grodd: SA [1]
Cold: SA [1] KO [1] DFD [1]
Street Thug: SA [1]

vs.

Superclone's Legion of Superheroes (Visitor)

1) R Superman 100 (4/7) V19 @
[1 SA]
2) E Cosmic Boy 70 (6/6) S17 @
[3 AST]
3) R Batman 64 (4/6) X16
[3 SA][2 KO]
4) E Dawnstar KOed!
[1 SA][1 KO]

HO: I-12
LO: V-19, F-11


Special Object: 23) Telephone Booth (LO) -- A character occupying the same squares as this object can be dealt 1 pushing damage as a free action. - O-10

BFC: Fearless Assault

Map: Xavier’s Mansion (Outdoor)

http://www.ianparmenter.com/hcutils/...1&u6=x-240y173

Turn 12A:

Free: Perplex Damage

1) Batman Flurry AV 9 on Angle Man DV 17. Rolls (6,3) and (4,3). Hit with 3 to Funky. Miss on the second, should have perplexed attack I guess.

ERROR: I had Icicle at AV 17, but he is at AV 16. That means the second attack of Batman hits foe 3 more to Funky and a KO. This means that Cosmic Boy couldn't attack Funky

ERROR: 2) Cosmic Boy range attack on Funky. AV 10 on DV 14. Cosmic boy hits Funky for 3 damage and gets the KO.

2) Cosmic Boy on Captain Cold. AV 10 on DV 15. Roll of (5,3) for 3 to Captain Cold and the KO.

Free: Batman Outwits Incapacitate on Angle Man.

TMNT99's Darkseid’s Society (Home)

1) R Angle Man (Icicle; 4/6) W-15
2) U Lex Luthor* X-14 KO
3) R Killer Moth (Lex Corp Battlesuit) KO
4) R Gorilla Grodd KO
5) R Captain Cold KO
6) R Funky Flashman (Street Thug) KO

Icicle: DFD [4]
Lex: AST [2]
Grodd: SA [1]
Cold: SA [1] KO [1] DFD [1]
Street Thug: SA [1]

vs.

Superclone's Legion of Superheroes (Visitor)

1) R Superman 100 (4/7) V19
[1 SA]
2) E Cosmic Boy 70 (6/6) S17 @@
[1 SA][3 AST][1 KO]
3) R Batman 64 (4/6) X16 @
[5 SA][3 KO]
4) E Dawnstar KOed!
[1 SA][1 KO]

HO: I-12
LO: V-19, F-11


Special Object: 23) Telephone Booth (LO) -- A character occupying the same squares as this object can be dealt 1 pushing damage as a free action. - O-10

BFC: Fearless Assault

Map: Xavier’s Mansion (Outdoor)

http://www.ianparmenter.com/hcutils/...1&u6=x-337y218

Turn 12A:

Free: Perplex Damage

1) Batman Flurry AV 9 on Angle Man DV 17. Rolls (6,3) and (4,3). Hit with 3 to Funky. Miss on the second, should have perplexed attack I guess.

ERROR: I had Icicle at AV 17, but he is at AV 16. That means the second attack of Batman hits foe 3 more to Funky and a KO. This means that Cosmic Boy couldn't attack Funky

ERROR: 2) Cosmic Boy range attack on Funky. AV 10 on DV 14. Cosmic boy hits Funky for 3 damage and gets the KO.

2) Cosmic Boy on Captain Cold. AV 10 on DV 15. Roll of (5,3) for 3 to Captain Cold and the KO.

Free: Batman Outwits Incapacitate on Angle Man.

TMNT99's Darkseid’s Society (Home)

1) R Angle Man (Icicle; 4/6) W-15
2) U Lex Luthor* X-14 KO
3) R Killer Moth (Lex Corp Battlesuit) KO
4) R Gorilla Grodd KO
5) R Captain Cold KO
6) R Funky Flashman (Street Thug) KO

Icicle: DFD [4]
Lex: AST [2]
Grodd: SA [1]
Cold: SA [1] KO [1] DFD [1]
Street Thug: SA [1]

vs.

Superclone's Legion of Superheroes (Visitor)

1) R Superman 100 (4/7) V19
[1 SA]
2) E Cosmic Boy 70 (6/6) S17 @@
[1 SA][3 AST][1 KO]
3) R Batman 64 (4/6) X16 @
[5 SA][3 KO]
4) E Dawnstar KOed!
[1 SA][1 KO]

HO: I-12
LO: V-19, F-11


Special Object: 23) Telephone Booth (LO) -- A character occupying the same squares as this object can be dealt 1 pushing damage as a free action. - O-10

BFC: Fearless Assault

Map: Xavier’s Mansion (Outdoor)

http://www.ianparmenter.com/hcutils/...1&u6=x-337y218

Toss up a barrier around Batman, he takes a token and a clix.

TMNT99's Darkseid’s Society (Home)

1) R Angle Man (Icicle; 4/6) W-15@
2) U Lex Luthor* X-14 KO
3) R Killer Moth (Lex Corp Battlesuit) KO
4) R Gorilla Grodd KO
5) R Captain Cold KO
6) R Funky Flashman (Street Thug) KO

Icicle: DFD [4]
Lex: AST [2]
Grodd: SA [1]
Cold: SA [1] KO [1] DFD [1]
Street Thug: SA [1]

vs.

Superclone's Legion of Superheroes (Visitor)

1) R Superman 100 (4/7) V19
[1 SA]
2) E Cosmic Boy 70 (6/6) S17 @@
[1 SA][3 AST][1 KO]
3) R Batman 64 (3/6) X16 @@
[5 SA][3 KO]
4) E Dawnstar KOed!
[1 SA][1 KO]

HO: I-12
LO: V-19, F-11


Special Object: 23) Telephone Booth (LO) -- A character occupying the same squares as this object can be dealt 1 pushing damage as a free action. - O-10

BFC: Fearless Assault

Map: Xavier’s Mansion (Outdoor)

http://www.ianparmenter.com/hcutils/...1&u6=x-337y218