how on earth does one justify BEAST BOY as being the best, and Johnny quick as being the 10th? i understand that the prime version is both Titans and outiders, but still.
That just seems VERY ironic to me. johnny quick is very cost-effective, and REDICULOUSLY good as a 3rd attacker/support piece... just saying.

oh, and for the record, I agree with thugit, Alan scott is GOOD, but VERY overestimated and overrated. I can see how he could shine in 600+. Filling the roll of a secondary attacker, while supporting a tentpole(like crisis Spectre).

but i dont think he has the stats to really deal with a threat in 300-400.

I think the issue here is that thugit sees a 145 support piece as inherently bad, which many others do not, and to which I point out Metron used as a 195 pt support piece nearly won GenCon.

And Quick dies in 1 shot. Beast Boy is a scant 10 pts more and has not only the ta and tie up options, more clicks, hss, tons of damage, and even the dreaded big attack from 2 away. Its not close.

I agree with a few of your picks but problem I have with that last statement is that if you can't position a HSS To NOT BE hit then..."YOU'RE DOING IT WRONG"

In no particular order
Ares
Doomsday
Scar
Guy Gardner
Atrocitus
Superman (uncommon)
Batman (Super Rare)
White Lantern Ice
White Lantern Flash
White Lantern Superman

Two words INTERGANG AGENTS now Doomsday is walking around with OUTWIT and they're cheap enough to build a theme team at 300 pts.

...No Interngang agents have ...Monster...

With the new ATA, Bane and Ragdoll need to be top ten. Also: Metron is leaps and bounds better than Alan. Better stats, better powers and immunity to Outwit. That one isn't even close.

Oh totally. And I know have a reason to base people with Black Alice if she needs to DIE : P

Ragdoll with the ATA is now the best tie-up figure ever. Bane with the ATA is scary to anyone.

Deadshot man.

Sharpshooter, Stealth, and his special power. NOW WHen you get in close to cripple him and you accidentally kill him DANG Damage.

Deadshot's already there, but he would get quite the boost from the ATA.

Doomsday is so situational. You have to be playing Golden Age to make him work as well. Also, I'm not sure Doomsday even beats Atrocitus. Add a Red Lantern. Atrocitus packs an outwit and perplex with him (two Questions will do), then hits on a 6. Heavy Object - Doomsday is down to flurry with 3 damage. And Atrocitus should get the first hit thanks to move and attack up front. After that, well, it's over.

Yes, Metron is mostly better, for 50 points more. And you under-rate TK.

As far as HSS, you do realize Beast Boy has it too right?

I don't underrate TK. I said it's Alan's best use.

So, TK-ing in some Gotham, Stealthed, Outwitters who pack a punch, Running Shot in for 3 penetrating damage with 11 attack or 10 attack and 4 damage with plenty of theme PC, isn't good enough? Especially with a Gotham City Detective (which puts him up to still barely more than Hal Jordan SR). Gotham has serious mobility issues. In one fell swoop, he offers a solution to that along with serious damage and ranged support.

I can say that I ran him at the center of a Gotham City team, and in 2 of 3 matches he took exactly one click of damage. He EXCEEDED my expectations.

Cap, OTOH, is cheaper, and an astounding figure up front, but hit him once and, well, better hope it was in close combat, cause if it was at range, he's dead within a round.

Also, Indomitable is fantastic, and makes for some great Batman-chucking fun.