just checking in.

Ok, after looking at the situation, here is what I've come up with.

On Turn 3A, the following is posted:



So the turn and the recap are posted correctly. The rules in the league are that the recap takes precedent over the map link when there is a mixup.

Also, the #2 and #3 tokens for Cosmic Boy/Sun Boy tokens have been flipped the entire game since Turn 1 it looks like, so there would be little reason to think that Token 2 was actually Cosmic Boy as it hasn't been right for him the entire game.

So as for the initial question on the flip-flop between Cosmic Boy/Sun Boy, it is a play on situation.

The only thing that keeps this from being a total slam dunk is the mixup between the map and the recap/turn on him being in C-13 or D-13. Because it was posted in the turn AND recap as D-13, that is the position, even if it is less advantageous. However, that would have had to be noticed before Turn 3B had completed for it to be addressed, and no illegal actions occured due to the mixup. If Great A takes his turn and outwits Sun Boy because he was in listed in D-13, he would have been totally in the right to do so. However that was noticed after the fact.

It is my official position that since there were no illegal actions taken because of the mix up, there is nothing to go back to in any kind of rewind.

So unfortunately, this is a play on situation.


Now, onto the next order of business. On the turn posted thus far for 4A:

Now, if he is listing all these targets, the only way he could be doing that is Pulse Wave, so the fact that captkool didn't specifically say " Sun Boy RS to G-17 and PULSE WAVE...." will be overlooked as it is kind of implied.

However, no where in the description is the term "Nova Blast" used. And that makes a HUGE difference. There are legitimate reasons why one would not use Nova Blast, so it cannot just be assumed. It would have to be declared that Nova Blast is being used BEFORE making the attack roll.

Now, if in the roll that was sent via e-mail to Great A included the term Nova Blast in the description, it will still count, but if it did not, then this will be just a standard Pulse Wave which will only do 1 damage to all targets hit, and no clicks given to Sun Boy afterward, (other than the standard push click)

Also, as a final note, Scandal Savage is also going to be hit by this Pulse Wave, whether it is determined to be a Nova Blast or not. She is on the diagonal LoF from G-17 because of the wall she just busted down.


So, long post there but here is the skinny:

1) Cosmic Boy/Sun Boy mixup is a play-on. (Though it should be corrected next map link)

2) While position was also done wrong, it wasn't noticed until after the turn was completed. Because there is no illegal actions done on 3B, there is nothing to go back to, so it is a play-on.

3) In the turn, Nova Blast was not declared, so unless it was declared in the e-mail sent for the dice roll, it is a standard Pulse Wave. No Nova Blast.

4) Scandal Savage is also a target of this attack.

dang....i forgot to Nova Blast ouch. continuing with turn.

actually, waiting on original PC instructions GA.

No PC for pulsewave.

pause for PC Dawny v wasp at J-20

black panther will take token for pc

4A:

Deadman lead fail

1) Scandal BCF the wall rolls 6 becomes 3 still breaks down wall at D14/D15

2) +3 AV on Sun Boy RS to G-17 for a 4 range v Wasp,Hawkeye,Panther and tigra 13 v 17,18,15,15 rolls 3,4=7 hits all for one click including scandal

3) Live Wire to I-16 (All WCs Mystics still)

4) Dawnstar HSS to J-20 v Wasp 9+1 (quarry back as Panther OW gone) =10 v 16 rolls 6,2=8 BP takes theme PC token PCed to a roll=9 senses is a 6 end move at J-20

LOSH

1. R Live Wire 22pts (4/4) I-16@
2. E Sun Boy 79pts (5/6) G-17@@
w/Nova BLast 10pts
w/ Protected 8 (used)
3. R Cosmic Boy 45pts (5/5) J-11
4. V Deadman 87pts (6/6) G-10
w/Contingency Plan 12pts
5. E Scandal Savage 60pts* (5/6) D-14
6. E Dawnstar 60pts (6/6) J-20@@
w/Armor Piercing 10pts
7. Legionairre 4pts (1/1) J-12

*ATA: Secret Six 3 pts

Total: 400 pts

Objects: Standard objects only. (None submitted)

VS.

GreatAurelius' AVENGERS (BRONZE AGE)

1. E Wasp (CW) 77pts (4/5) K-21@
w/ Contingency Plan 12pts %%
2. LE Victor Shade 91pts (8/8) H-23@
w/ Not So Special 3pts
3. E Hawkeye (CW) 98pts* (5/6) I-19 SA: 1
4. R Black Panther 27pts (2/4) J-21@@
5. R Tigra 40pts (5/6) H-18@
6. R Ant-Man (SV) 48pts (6/6) K-23 AST: 1

*ATA: Great Lakes Avengers 3pts (x1)

Total: 399pts

LO: C-12, H-12
HO: N-13

BFC: POWER DAMPENING FIELD
Damage values higher than 3 become 3 instead.

Map: Sciencells

map link not working.

Player 2 turn 4

Vision will perplex up Tigra's attack to 9

Tigra will try to kick up side the head Sun boy 9av+roll(6,1)=16 hits and does for 2. She pushes.

Hawkeye will try to break away and gets a 6 to RS to J-18 and go for Savage 11av+roll(6,1)=18 hits for 2 but only 1 after toughness.

Vision, Black Panther, Wasp and Ant-man will take PC token

CP token
------------------
LOSH

1. R Live Wire 22pts (4/4) I-16@
2. E Sun Boy 79pts (3/6) G-17@@
w/Nova BLast 10pts
w/ Protected 8 (used)
3. R Cosmic Boy 45pts (5/5) J-11
4. V Deadman 87pts (6/6) G-10
w/Contingency Plan 12pts
5. E Scandal Savage 60pts* (4/6)@ D-14
6. E Dawnstar 60pts (6/6) J-20@@
w/Armor Piercing 10pts
7. Legionairre 4pts (1/1) J-12

*ATA: Secret Six 3 pts

Total: 400 pts

Objects: Standard objects only. (None submitted)

VS.

GreatAurelius' AVENGERS (BRONZE AGE)

1. E Wasp (CW) 77pts (4/5) K-21
w/ Contingency Plan 12pts %%
2. LE Victor Shade 91pts (8/8) H-23 AST:1
w/ Not So Special 3pts
3. E Hawkeye (CW) 98pts* (5/6) J-18@ SA: 2
4. R Black Panther 27pts (2/4) J-21
5. R Tigra 40pts (3/6) H-18@@
6. R Ant-Man (SV) 48pts (6/6) K-23 AST: 1

*ATA: Great Lakes Avengers 3pts (x1)

Total: 399pts

LO: C-12, H-12
HO: N-13

BFC: POWER DAMPENING FIELD
Damage values higher than 3 become 3 instead.

Map: Sciencells


http://www.ianparmenter.com/hcutils2...-4&u12=x399y28

the wall at between d-14/D-15 is broken....hawkeye does not have LoF to Scandal from where he took the shot. the wall at between D & E-14 still stands.

Was thinking the other way. No probelm Going to have Hawkeye RS next to Vision at G-22 and go for Sun boy. Sending roll now

Miss with a 5 but PC from Ant-man to 9; hits for 2 on sunboy and hawkeye takes a mystic damage.

i don't think you have any PCs left.....one last turn and one in turn 2. it's 2 per 300 right? i know somehting changed with PC theme rules so i'm not sure.

I have 4 in 400 pt game; so got 1 more remaining.

5A:

Deadman lead 6 success

1) LW push to H-22 (all WCs currently Mystics)

2) Legionnaire to I-13

3) Coss Tks Deadman to J-13

4) Deadman phase to I-23

CP token



LOSH

1. R Live Wire 22pts (3/4) H-22@@
2. E Sun Boy 79pts (1/6) G-17
w/Nova BLast 10pts
w/ Protected 8 (used)
3. R Cosmic Boy 45pts (5/5) J-11@
4. V Deadman 87pts (6/6) I-23@
w/Contingency Plan 12pts $
5. E Scandal Savage 60pts* (5/6) D-14
6. E Dawnstar 60pts (6/6) J-20
w/Armor Piercing 10pts
7. Legionairre 4pts (1/1) I-13@

*ATA: Secret Six 3 pts

Total: 400 pts

Objects: Standard objects only. (None submitted)

VS.

GreatAurelius' AVENGERS (BRONZE AGE)

1. E Wasp (CW) 77pts (4/5) K-21
w/ Contingency Plan 12pts %%
2. LE Victor Shade 91pts (8/8) H-23 AST:1
w/ Not So Special 3pts
3. E Hawkeye (CW) 98pts* (5/6) J-18@ SA: 2
4. R Black Panther 27pts (2/4) J-21
5. R Tigra 40pts (3/6) H-18@@
6. R Ant-Man (SV) 48pts (6/6) K-23 AST: 1

*ATA: Great Lakes Avengers 3pts (x1)

Total: 399pts

LO: C-12, H-12
HO: N-13

BFC: POWER DAMPENING FIELD
Damage values higher than 3 become 3 instead.

Map: Sciencells

http://www.ianparmenter.com/hcutils2...04&u12=x399y28