Closing thread until I can tally/write up.

Stupid poem takes way longer than a normal writeup.

Final Vote Count

Quebbs: killingjoke
MP07 JJJ: Darkstone
Roy: Sloonei, JoH, Quebbs, JJJ
No Lynch: Silver
Sloonei: adamical, Roy, I_R

LHLV: Roy


Day 3

As I looked all up ‘round from where he was laid,
I saw more rainbows than a gay pride parade!
Round the bend of the river, as I watched it float,
Came eight big ol’ gators, pulling a boat.
He dumped a whole mess o’ crawdads from his sack,
Twasn’t enough to save him or his friend in black.

Roy has been lynched! He was Pere Noel (Mafia).


Night 3 begins now. You have 36 hours (though I’d prefer you don’t use all that time so I can work the schedule a little better).

Night 3

I heard the blast of a trumpet; the place came alive,
For look! He was here! He had finally arrived!
He passed throwing cookies and oranges and treats,
Then he paused just to take a drink of something sweet.
Meanwhile a list was being checked twice,
‘Fore its maker was visited by somebody not nice,
He knew when kids slept, and when they awoke,
But when these horses drove by, they weren’t there to joke.

Silver Lantern is dead! He was Santa Claus (Town).

Day 4 begins now. You have 36 hours.

You certainly had a lot of fun yesterday after I Went to bed. Interesting to see a scum lynch with such a narrow margin, it certainly gives us things to work with.

Present on the scum lynch:
Jackofhearts2005
Quebbster
Sloonei
JaggedJimmyJay

Actively voting for someone else:
adamical
Immortal_Raven

Absent:
Afrcngy
killingjoke101
The Darkstone

We have claims from Afrcngy and killingjoke as well as a partial claim from adamical, but I don't Think we know anything about Immortal_Raven or The Darkstone. Is that correct?

I claimed Santa.

It's not that I thought Roy was a bad lynch, but I felt Sloonei was a better one. adam claims to have JKed me N1 and Sloonei claims to have succeeded in targeting me N1. Given that I failed, Sloonei seemed the more solid lynch.

And to whoever blocked me last night, thanks.

No offense, but claiming Santa in this game means very little.

While true, I did claim it awhile back.

And I didn't object to Roy's lynch. I simply thought there were better options. Yay for plurality where we don't need an outright majority.

vote: Sloonei

As much as Sloonei voted for Roy, selling one's scum teammate down the river is a standard move. And if the logic used on Roy is inconsistency in night actions/results, then we should go after Sloonei as well.

Giving Quebbster a strong pass for now.

Agreed with his logic. Immortal Raven and Adam likely encompass one or two scum. Surprised KJ didn't kill one of them, honestly.

I feared being MD'd into someone after my claim yesterday.

Sloonei already claimed and we are at the very beginning of the phase. This is not a good way to go. Now I'm even more curious about you.

If Sloonei and Roy are mafia together, then there would be no reason for any scum players to switch their votes unless Roy had a significantly better power or looked way better in the town's eyes, both of which are not very likely.

Ergo, Sloonei is almost certainly not scum with Adam or Raven.

Solution: Lynch Raven and/or Adam and give ourselves a very good chance of confirming Sloonei.

Untrue, I voted for JJJ last phase.

Still parsing out thoughts over the Roy lynch.

You didn't participate in the Roy/Sloonei kerfluffle at the end of the phase. I consider the fact that you had already voted for someone else irrelevant.

Too true. I_R, power and targets, please. I know you claim that you were blocked. I wasn't on the Roy lynch, so I am not entirely writing you off as scum, but want to hear more from you.

Vote: Immortal_Raven

I admit, maybe I made a mistake by voting for Sloonei in light of Roy flipping as scum. But that's only confirmed once we know Sloonei's alignment and only if he's town.

But you still didn't address my reasoning. adam claims JKer. No one refutes it. He claims to have JKed me night 1. I claimed failure immediately on D2. Sloonei also claims to have targeted me N1. Yet should have failed since adam succeeded.

Ergo, if you want a better scum read, lynching adam or Sloonei would be smarter.

I'll agree that Quebbs the neutral gets a pass for now.