He's obviously scum trying to get me lynched for pushing on all his shadiness OR he really is a jester and is using this as another straw to get himself lynched... I.e. I autopsy as town, and of course then the town will lynch him...

Serial Killers are neutral by default.

Yes, but there are friendly neutrals as well. I'm asking how the alignment cop got a result of neutral and then concluded that it must be the SK.

Interesting power. Are we in Jericho?

Yeah, cause anagrams of characters and powers are terribly difficult. I mean, I make them so easy it hurts, and people complain anyway. I'll give you guys one or two more chances before I just eliminate clue cops altogether. Totally not mad, but it's fun to pretend. Kind of like I pretend to be smart at work.

He didn't get a result of neutral OR SK... Why are you talking as if what he's saying is true...

I AM TOWN...

He's lying to either get me lynched, and thus get himself lynched, or just to get my lynched period.

PRO TIP:

These are the kind of clues I'd like to see in games:

1) SL's Mother's maiden name?

2) Where SL went on his honeymoon?

3) The name of SL's first school?

Are we clear sir??!!

Alright here's the deal. I'm not a fan of going 3 days in a row without a lynch given how kontrol says the town is getting hit pretty hard. If zyx is a jester, I'm not voting for him. Remember Alderan. If zyx is telling the truth, then SL is bad news. If that happens, maybe we can get a good idea what the themes are. Seems like I have only one obvious choice unless someone else poses another theory. Vote: SL

I really do hate pointing this out.

Like, feel like an utter bastard for pointing this out.

But zyxba is a claimed cop. How do we know, exactly, that he wasn't misdirected or had his stuff fiddled with? I'm also going to vomit in my mouth as I point out that nobody killed him.

Between what he's saying, and the pineapple in the writeup, I'm feeling that whoever he targeted, is indeed a killer. I don't think there's any denying that much.

We need a little more rationality, and little less hysterics.

For now: Remove Vote

I'd like for Zyx and Silver to unbind their panties and start focusing on the rest of the players. You're probably both town and you're going to waste a ton of our damned time.

Then run your own game.

Aside from the 18 theories that some of us have already pointed out you mean?

Touche!!!

filler

There is no doubt in my mind that Zyxba is scum... He's lied so much this game that I can't believe it's not butter...

That is a good point about him being messed with though...

>_<

You are missing the point. Logic demands that you analyze a claim as if it were factual to determine if conflicts with other known facts. If what zyxba says is true (namely 1. he is an alignment cop, not a role cop, and 2. he claims to have discovered that S.L. is a serial killer), then he must be basing his assertion on getting a neutral result.

When compounded with the fact that some SKs have a town cloak (I'm not sure how often) and there are town-friendly neutrals, zyxba's claim is suspect. I'm not saying S.L. is town or neutral, or that zyxba is lying, I am merely asking how he got his conclusion based on his powers. I am asking a question to determine his veracity. How can I say this any clearer?

One thing that piqued my interest is that both times you've claimed to be town, it's been hidden in other things. One of them was hidden in a wall of text after you challenged zyx to truth check you. Tell you what. If you post "I am town" by itself and nothing more in the same post, I will remove my vote to give a lie detector a chance to look into you if we have one. If someone doesn't come forward tomorrow to clear you, my vote goes back onto you unless we have a better target. Deal?

My post was directed at this statement, btw. Now there is a lot of posts in between.