OH that is freakin' fantastic. I am the suspect one now. Oh what logic. I came on and said I was silenced but I AM THE GUILTY ONE.

Night 1 tyro targets coyotejack
Night 2 nothing because of what happened/silenced
Night 3 targeted H&C and i got back he targeted nobody/strange for a tracker, huh

I would like to know how many F'N days we are going to let H&C go without roleclaiming a character. GIVE ME AN F'N break.

I figure the only way to get this resolved and quit messing around is to vote for me. Since I called H&C out early after night 1 and he had plenty of time to roleclaim after he called tracker and hasn't we need to get rid of the obvious mafia player which is me. :cross-eye

Go ahead I don't mind. If H&C is a townie tracker also I don't very much like the way he has ignored repeated attempts just to name his character. Not much of a townie really. Instead we are stuck on like the third day in a row not knowing who he is and we end up chasing our own tails.

Yes, it worked out that way didn't it. However, there was no way for the town to know that.

Meaning vote piling at the end looks, odd.

Hang on, now. I'm only asking questions. I don't have notes, so I expect there are things I don't remember.

Besides, somebody is silenced today, right? Its not crazy to wonder if it could be H&C. The only evidence we have that you were the one silenced the other day is your word. If you were in my place, wouldn't you be considering both angles?

I'm not out and out accusing you or claiming I'm sure you or H&C are mafia. I think one of you might be.

Also, keep in mind the guy pondering these possibilities is the first person in this thread to ever vote to lynch H&C, something that I got a small amount of heat for doing.

Oh, and for what its worth, I am not subscribing to the JoH theory that all votes for H&C are suspect.

Change Vote: Morpheusdr3am3r

I think there's something fishy with Morpheusdr3am3r.


First we get this response to my calling out Truffle:
I'll admit it's not that incriminating. He's not outrigth defending Pilgrim, but wants to know more - is he digging for info, or covering himself if Truff turns out to be town?

Then we get:

Which looks to me like stalling more than anything else. I'm not opposed to talking though, as I said in a previous post. It's Morph's next post that has me wondering...

So here we have someone hesitant to vote off Truffle, but almost eager to string up H&C. AT least that's how I read it.

Has Morph claimed or hinted a claim yet?

Come on guys. We need to string up that shady Shadow40. I am positive he is mafia. He is sneaky that way. Plus we string him up we get all kinds of information.

Lynch Tally

Havoc&Chaos: Tyroman, HZ, TVK, Stranger, MorphD, Kontrol, Vicious Buddah,
WadeWilson: JoH & Pax, MBauers, Maniac
JackofHearts: WadeWilson
MorpheousDr3am3r: Anonym0use

Why are we still voting for H&C?

My question exactly.

Not at all. But I don't do what a known mafia player tells me to do. Its bad business. Somebody can investigate H&C and then we can decide what to do about him.

I think more likely than not both H&C and Shadow are town. We've had two trackers in 15 player games. Vision has been known to have two reverse trackers. Its silly to think that because Shadow is town, H&C must be mafia or vice versa.

As for Morpheous, I agree, he seems scummy.

I just think Wade seems a lot more scummy. He's saying the exact same things Truffle was saying. Truffle is mafia.

I think it's on H&C cause he's had multiple phases to come out and claim a character and hasn't. I'm willing to switch but I'd really like a name.

Nevermind, I just realized the logical pitfall with the H&C issue

vote: WadeWilson

Course the logic hole only applies if H&C is mafia. If he's the Dwarf, then it still fits.

So, truthfully I still want a name.

Here's the thing. We had a whole Night phase for people to check out H&C, and no one came up with anything?

So our course of action is

1.) -We Lynch H&C.

a.) We find out he's Town and feel stupide

b.) we find out he's mafia...

Then what? What do we go on the next day?

Alternatively, we could...

2.) Pressure/Lynch Morph and/or Wade today and get a claim of some sort or a reason they're acting twitchy.

I prefer option 2. Plenty of people can deal with H&C tonight if necessary.