I consider Cap the best, or, at least, a top 5 piece in the game, so saying Alan isn't quite as good? Not an insult.

ummm no. doomsday can throw a light object from 8 away and hit atrocitus for 2 straight through. after just two clicks, good luck hitting that 19. once based, doomsday will smash him for 5 and it's pretty much over. the penetrating damage is what makes doomsday take just about anyone down. no brick can really stand up to him. supes only beats him if he hits and runs!

On what planet with 98 points of support am I leaving Atrocitus open to a thrown object before I'm in charge range.

The same planet where Doomsday just stands there waiting to be Charged.

It varies between players....it just seems like you can argue either side.

Troma is correct. Throwing hypothetical teams at each other is a waste of time.

Just like Johnny Quick Vs .beast boy.

Beast Boy...for only ten points more has more options...so I can see how he'd RANK HIGHER But not on your list at all...well I guess that's your prerogative

Err, Beast Boy is #1.

Sorry typo meant to say that "Johnny Quick not on your list at all..."

With his 6 Speed, Doomsday could very well be doing just that in a 300-point game. Generally speaking, Atrocitus is going to have first shot. The question is if Atrocitus can survive Doomsday's counterattack.

Quick is #10.

well damn it I'm slow....Why the hell are people complaining...Beast boy ...providing you have all his forms has sooo many options for what he can do....
So how does Bane not make your list?

I was wondering the same thing. Personally, I would think Bane ranks higher than Ice. Her double incapacitate is good, but not when compared to Bane as a whole.

The ATA totally gets Bane close to the list, which I guess kicks off Quick, but, again, its close. Bane is almost half of a 300 pt. team with the ATA, and I'm not crazy about that many points being a suicide bomb, although, again, it's close.

And Rouroni, if you pack Outwit with Atrocitus, he's using Outwit after hitting Doomsday to take out that Flurry. No Flurry, no killing Atrocitus, and then Atrocitus wins. Even without that, I'd take an Outwitter or two to kill a severely weakened Doomsday.

...why couldn't he...just you know pack an outwitter...or an Intergang agent....outwit Atrocitus' Charge...And even if Atrocitus gets the Alpha Strike (I Know hypothetical teams but in THIS SITUATION)

He Flurries back Doing six damage as well. Using his unused outwit (because he obviously didn't use it on Charge) To outwit Atroctius Invulnerability.