I'm kind of a stranger to Stranger's games...

Would he give someone a lynch proof role?

Ehhh. He's not really aligned with the police, in fact he's often against the rank and file. Maybe a mafia-friendly neutral? Does Stranger usually do neutral themes?

My vote isn't on you at the moment, but I'm leaning GCPD who was trying to buddy up to town.

Oh yeah. It's a sore point for me.

vote Brainiac

I'm not really ok with JoH, but there doesn't seem like much more he is going to give us right now.

Count me among those who'd like a full claim from brainy.

Though I think he said he would pull back on that, but I wasn't in the last couple so I don't know if that has happened. (Yes, I know I should look at the ones I wasn't in, but fresh start and I didn't want to skew my thinking with any old combos).

Hahahahahahahahahahahahaha.

*ahem*

He has in the past, but I believe the focus for this game is simpler, weaker powers - more along the lines of a regular mafia game (although clearly with his own spin - the S mechanic).

With the rules of the current game focused more on day activity and limiting night actions, I would be surprised if anyone was purely lynch-proof thus game.

Check out Roy's role from last game. Then tell me my claim is too weird.

Ditto on the 'grats and sentiment.

Color me shocked that no one wanted to power claim/say they had a good power on day 2. If anything that reads as very scummy: either you "mark" a townie with a good power or out a scummer looking for a discount(either to make yourself look good, or to suss out your opposing mafia). You also say that if Rokk's power was investigative, he'd use it on you, which would be no help... besides, ya'know, clearing your name and giving our other info gatherers better places to look.

Instead you took a 50/50 shot at help the mafia because Nifty *might* have an info gathering power.

I asked for existing power claims, not new ones.

^Here's my post.

^And my other.

I do not feel like either post requests anyone put at target on their back.

But you can clearly see how it would though right?

Someone says "Yes, JoH, I'd love to have a 20% reduction"

They aren't saying that because they have s bunk power, they have a power they would like to use.

Regardless you gave it to Nifty instead of Rokk or ERS.

Before we get off on one direction too much, I am wondering: are people satisfied with the loganspeedo situation where he was oblivious to the whole bit about his powers costing anything?

Not entirely. He's currently third on my suspect list (Brainiac the drive-by Maniac, and JackO the RhinO being ahead of him at the moment).