i'll throw a pressure vote on St-Dumas for now, but i'm still curious about the day 2 joh/rokk copping result. that was not answered to my satisfaction. and the town has taken a huge hit already we have lost a lot of townies and some major key roles. if we believe rokk, we lost our cop, tracker, doctor and i actually thought iceman would;ve been a blocker of some type. change vote: St. Dumas

In a word, yes.

Rokk's counterargument will be "But Magneto was not in the same brotherhood as Mystique. Also, I was masoned with Chuck."

The counterargument to that is "The mod might not care but I can't prove it. You could have killed Chuck and janitored his body."

The counterargument to that is "Okay. I did not but I can't prove it."


Still, I find the idea that there is a brotherhood mafia (one of two?) the most important piece of evidence so far and it makes me more inclined to lynch Rokk than anyone else.

Gotta read what was said after my post first, though.

Ive been real confused this game so I guess Ill follow with some pressure.

Pressure Vote St. Dumas

I tend to let misdirects trump blockings, but I would definitely make a MD-nexus blockable. No one should be untouchable.

Incorrect

I still don't believe vlad's role or powers and his attempt to start a vote for an inactive instead of piecing info together for pressure on active player's seals the deal.

Lynch:vlad3theimpaler

Misdirection nexuses are much more common on this site than roleblocking nexuses (nexi?). Targeting a guy who claims roleblocking nexus is no wiser than targeting a guy who claims misdirection nexus.

That said, looking back at the post where I thought Rokk is claimed misdirection nexus, he was telling Tyro his results would be wonky. I thought Tyro had said he had targeted Rokk, which wasn't the case.

Well, someone wanted him dead. They either didn't buy the neutral survivor bit or they didn't care. As a known neutral, it wasn't the town's prerogative to protect him and I can't really feel bad for that considering he claimed so early and well...better him than a townie as even neutral survivors will generally side with scum in the end.

Madrox could (obviously doesn't since you're asking, as you would know or Madrox is dead and janitored) have a power that allows him to have a certain number of lives or to bodyguard other people, with one of his duplicates dying instead.

When this happens, it would say "a Madrox was killed" or something along those lines. As it was janitored, it instead said "Something was killed. He was ???"

Obviously not a Madrox but I imagine whatever was killed was a part of a player's role, not a player.

You can't pressure a player that isn't playing.



Why are we voting for Dumas? We should be voting for one of the two claimed brotherhood players.

Are you claiming Mystique?

Yes

filler

Cool.

Vote: H&C

I would groan at that vote but I'm starting to think JOH is scum so he's just playing the hand he's dealt.

Yeah I'm totally scum for voting for Mystique when we've got townies showing up killing people in the writeup.

You're free to provide an alternate interpretation of the writeup but where I'm sitting, Mystique is killing people at night.

Why would we think you have a kill power if I had you targeting vlad and he's still alive?

Though I guess there's this from the Night, but it happens after the decap...

I am curious, though, where anyone gets Mystique making a kill? (Other than tyro saying he's Deadpool - could that be separate from "Deadpool & Cable" or could the Chases be a Mafia? - and didn't make a kill?)

Based on the Night write-up where the person moving two people was forced to move two other people, I am curious about this.

(Also of interest? Why would people keep targeting a proclaimed Misdirection Nexus? )

2 nights ago, Predator X makes a kill. FMF (Predator X and a townie) says he didn't do it.

Last night, Deadpool makes a kill. Tyroman (Deadpool) says he didn't do it.

You have someone looking like characters making kills. Mystique is a character that can look like anyone.

Therefore, the logical conclusion is that Deadpool and Predator X are indeed not making kills on accident but that Mystique is killing people in an attempt to frame them.

How do we get that Predator-X made a kill just because it was someone beastly?

As noted, Deathverine or others could be just as beastly and making a kill.

I do see the Deadpool kill and agree that there could be a few problems there, not the least of which is tyro should not have been targeting anyone (though, again, the Night write-up shows what I feel is my Reverse Busdriving being led astray so that doesn't clear tyro as much as I would like.)

Heck, maybe there are Marauders - Gambit (forgot he was in the set and could also count for Horsemen), Mystique, Sabretooth, Karima - in the game or maybe Mystique's an SK.

I would say "Why is H&C being so open about his role?" but now I remember why. (You do remember, though, that H&C was on my case as much as you were the other Day?)

(Oh, and your "counter-counter-arguement" is wrong. I would have instead said, "Odds that I would have said I had a mason, killed an inactive and then got the perfect mason partner result in Chuck?"

Again, though, I still feel Darqles "goofed" a bit when he dropped the comment about Brotherhood. As if he was trying to implicate me and, at the time, I hadn't said whether I was Chuck or Magneto...so how did DF know I was Magneto and not Chuck?


Lynch Vote: H&C