The town "Ask the Mod"? Really?

Um, excuse me while I call BS, particularly in light of the obtuse clue that Space Jawa got for Sigdr. That and the fact that we have a cop, a clue cop, AND now apparently an unmisdirectable "yeah I can ask anything I want and there's nothing that can be done about it hahaha" cop. I somehow doubt Darq would put that into the game.

I'm Empress, formerly ensign, Hoshi Sato from ST: Enterprise. And yes, I'm town. I'm actually a hider, and hid with Magnito night 1 and kontrol night 2. I did receive a perk Night 1, but I don't feel like that should be disclosed at this time, just because that might out someone else and I don't want to do that to them.

Frankly, you've convinced me that YOU are scum and buddies with Silver Lantern. Especially since the character he has is not the bodyguarding type.

malakim claims to have targeted you last night

Day 3 Vote Tally

Silver (7): kontrol, Raven, zyxba, gFish, Rokk, Mal, +Kness
zyxba (1): Silver,
Mal (1): spworld

+Kness tied to Rokk

19 players, 10 for majority. Light updates from me today.

I gotta say Mal, I can see why people fear you in this game. You really are very good at distracting from the point and trying to turn a perfectly legit claim back on someone... But on this one, you've reached a bit.

Why on gods green earth would ANYONE try to protect a SK? I mean really? The whole point of the SK is that they're a threat to positively everyone. I am not trying to protect an SK. I am trying to find and identify scum. And this time, I got lucky and I found one.

And yes, we do seem to have quite a bit of info gathering, assuming everyone who's claimed hasn't lied. But in this case, I am most assuredly not lying. You're not town.

Anyways, Townies? Who do you want to Lynch first? do you want to finish the SL lynch and then move on Mal? Or do you want to lynch Mal first and hit SL tomorrow?

Fwhat?

This is the second time this week I've seen someone saying "I'm town" and other people like "Whelp, good enough for me."

You said "Here is the script to read off of. Say exactly this and lie or truth, I won't vote for you."

What makes you think a scummer wouldn't say "I am town" in that situation?

I am. Absolutely I am.

Common neutrals:
Serial killer - kills people every night
Cult recruiter - recruits people into a scum group every night
Survivor - sides with the mafia in the endgame
Bounty hunter - roughly a 50/50 shot he's going after a townie
Jester - causes all sorts of problems for the town

I don't see any reason to let any neutral live unless the mafia is just kicking your butt or the neutral is a claimed survivor/bounty hunter and has been helpful to the town.

Thawmus protecting Silver makes me want to vote for Silver. Same for Gfish. The fact that they're attacking each other, too, just makes me think that only one of them is a scumbuddy to Silver.

Silver's power claim is not what I'd expect but then again, my power isn't what I'd expect for my character, either. Then again, I think I know why. For Silver? I can only think of his character protecting one person, who she later had killed.

It wouldn't be the mod's fault if you showed up in the writeup killing people and then claimed as yourself.

That's one of the four arguments that never seems to sway me. The others being "I don't lie" "I'm a better mafia player than that" and "I am town."




On another note, I'm 95% convinced that Malakim is mafia and I'd rather lynch him today if we have the time. I'll go for 95% over a 70% chance, which is about how I'm feeling about the Silver Lantern lynch.

Is this 24 or 48 hours?

36. Leaves about 13 hours and 15 minutes.

Vote: Malakim2099

Well, I think Silver is the SK and mal is mafia. I tend to get rid of a SK first since they're often souped up and less likely to be able to be blocked, doctored, etc...

I'm actually down with a mal lynch, but I'd prefer to get Silver today. What say the rest of you? Plenty of time left, but let's not dally.

Or we block the sker because there's only one of him. We block Mal, that won't stop the mafia kill.

Plus, the sker can't rush a lynch or gain majority. The mafia is far more dangerous unless it's day one or two.

Skers that are immune to blocking or jailkeeping are few.

Here's what I want to do:
vote mal
spwt, could you ask if Silver's claim is accurate tonight? Bodyguard is very odd for Danaerys...

I don't trust Silver. The power doesn't match the role. The description of the girl being stopped by the force field on Night 1 matches up with Dany really well, and on the same night it looked like there was a pair of woman killing Max Black, so it would make sense for Dany to be the serial killer.

I'll lynch the serial killer over a scum any day of the week. I'd much rather eliminate a kill entirely.

Not saying I trust Malakim, or Gfish, because I don't. But Silver is my preferred target today.

The flip side of that is eliminating the SKer eliminates one Nightkill entirely.

I agree with all the stuff you said, but the flip side is more meta and gives us time to whittle down more scummers since there will be fewer Nightkills. Just depends which one we want to do. Both have pros and cons.

Man, it took me a long time to organize my thoughts. So long, that a post that I could have just said "I agree" to appeared.

No. If we lynch he serial killer today, we eliminate one kill for one night, one kill that won't happen anyways because Silver will be blocked tonight.

There is only one true difference between lynching a mafia player and the serial killer at this stage of the game and that is that the mafia has more votes and might use them tomorrow.

Lynching Silver tomorrow will be easy. Eliminate another 3, 4 players? Lynching Mal tomorrow might get difficult.

You don't have to trust Silver to lynch Malakim today. It's the mafia who would argue it is better to lynch maybe the serial killer than definitely a mafia member.