I think I get what you're saying: he's not actually unlynchable... just highly unlikely to be lynched.

Players (23):

1) Rokk_Krinn - Town 3/5. Writeup confirmed but like Pax says, almost too easy. Still, very likely town.
2) RenegadeRoy - Scum 3/5*. See previous post.
3) Space Jawa - Town 1/5*. Didn't vote for a player I know is town. That would be a tempting thing to give up if he was scum.
4) EnsRedShirt - Town 3/5. Ballsy move to take Rokk's bet. Too ballsy if he's scum, imo.
5) DestructoBoy - No read.
6) SkullBrother47 - No read.
7) brainiacFTW - Scum 1/5. See Bob's recent post. My biggest suspect is voting for him. Several players are voting elsewhere for poor/unexplained reasons. Mostly washes but kinda scummy.
10) grizzzadams - No read.
11) Linkor - No read.
13) Anathae - Scum 1/5*. Asks others if she should switch her vote. Doesn't care who gets lynched. Just wants to be part of the crowd.
14) colonialbob - Town 1/5. Feels town. Bob's tricky, though.
15) The Darkstone - No read.
16) JohannaMason - No read.
18) rorschachparadox - Town 1/5. Feels town.
19) Iceman425 - Town 2/5. Gives reasons for his vote on me. Not choosing the easy lynch target cause I'm not one, implying he is voting based on actual belief.
20) malakim2099 - Scum 2/5*.See previous post.
21) Kontrol - No read.
22) Ignatz_Mouse - No read.
23) loganspeedo - No read.
25) PaxZRake - Town 1/5. Draws attention to himself by questioning Rokk. Dangerous move if he's scum, implying he's not. Doesn't jump on either train.
26) Girathon - Replaced. No read.
27) Jackofhearts2005 - Town 5/5. Role pm says so.
28) michiganj24 - No read.

Oh and *s note that if Brainiac is lynched, his flip will have an immediate effect on my read of that player.

That's like ranting about people guessing if a baby is going to be a boy or a girl. Just because the two are mutually exclusive doesn't mean they can't be the most likely two outcomes.

Not that I feel it is definitely one or the other, but trying to paint them as mutually exclusive and therefore equally undefendable is an odd play.

You're demanding I come up with a better target under threat of death.

But I'm not allowed to question anyone so you're trying to impose limitations on my ability to defend myself. Why should I accept that?

Or am I just not allowed to question you, specifically? What makes you above suspicion? What have you done for the town?

Well which is it? Was Nifty trying to make me look bad or make me look good? It's one or the other and if you can't answer that, you don't have a clue what my alignment is.

You act like you know my alignment must be bad cause you want me dead, not cause you suspect me. You want me dead because you're scum and I'm not aligned with you.

You keep saying that but you've provided no reasoning. Again, you just want to see the idea that I'm scum repeated regardless of evidence. That's a scummy attitude.

You look like you're trying to make two specific players look bad. You sure don't look like you're scum hunting to me.

The difference is there's no other option.

Boys and girls are not opposites. They're just your only two choices.

Let us both share an ooc moment of rip for the loss of our father's wonderful character.

Unrelated family joking aside, this whole thing with JoH is definitely rubbing me the wrong way, but I'm not sure I'm ready to cast in my vote just yet. Strong arguments from both sides.

Never stop spinning.

Bam! I have arrived!

I don't trust rokk, and my reasons are being kept on the low down till I have done some more looking into him. Just take everything he says with a pinch of salt for another couple phases.

I have only read the first and last phase of the day, is the prisoner free?

Prisoner is not free. Everyone seems to have forgotten about him.

Do we know who it is?

"I have nothing of substance to accuse you with or to defend myself with so I shall continue just repeating that Jack is spinning so as to not draw attention to this fact."

I'm not sure which I think it is (I also think you could be a neutral)...which is what I said... which is why I haven't voted for you. Why do you have such a hard on for me when there are literally 8 other people who are more suspicious of you than I am. Is it because I've been poking at your story all day when others haven't?

Until I switch targets. So essentially one night but I auto target whoever I last targeted if I miss using my power.

I just do the jailkeep but I assume that will essentially roleblock my actual target.

I'm not completely convince we need to lynch anyone today. We're down 3 mafiosos and only one (albeit seemingly important) townie. So anyone saying "Either JoH or Brainiac has to go!" is making me a bit leery.

That said of course, my vote sits on Brainiac and if he doesn't come back on to offer a reason he should be allowed to stick around and vote to free the fridge prisoner on day 4, I wouldn't feel upset about his lynch.