Oh but of course you did. Who's a big boy? Who's a big boy? Yes you are! I'll go get your bottle for you...

Yea, cause it was REAL tough to win with your role wasn't it

That game was sooo antiHCRealms town it wasn't funny.

That game was pure brilliance of not relying on your night actions and looking at behaviors.

I played my role BRILLIANTLY! Not my fault the town believes me when Human Torch was killing townies....

Hence why it wouldn't work here.

But is that really a bad thing?

It required more thought than anything else.

Yes.

I don't like losing before the game starts. It wasn't that dramatic, close.

The town lost N1, the rest of the game was just about seeing which of his mafia MSU could keep alive.

Pax, you had the entire mafia fingered.

If people listened to you instead of trying to lynch you and Mal I'm confident you would have won.

I agree with Doc...just because the Realms mafias rely on roleclaims doesn't mean it was a mafia given. There were two other mafia members with me that won. You are just cheesed that DF and I got the town to believe us over you. Hence, you had to go...

Also if Carl didn't Roleclaim day one it would have been VERY different.

If MSU was fishy and roleclaimed as Big Brain or Lockjaw, and not Human Torch, he would have been lynched.

Of course I had the entire mafia figured out. They played into my scumdar.

Doesn't mean I could have done anything about it. I'm pretty sure the only way that I could have gotten MSU lynched in that game is if mbauers, myself, and MSU were the only ones left alive, and bauers had thought it would be funny to have MSU vote for himself.

(I think mbauers was Hate Monger)

DBauers was Hate Monger.

MBauers was The Thing.

And shame on everyone in that game for not knowing Hate Monger appeared in Fantastic Four well before he was a Cap villain.

The town always believe you over me. I just except that.

Just like I accept that I'm usually right and you're usually wrong

But he did, and there went any chance I had of getting MSU lynched.

Extinguished, just like the Human Torch's flame.

(Now, if MSU had said, "Hey, Pax has been claiming as Gallowglass, that's totally my character!" I would have giggled)

The fact remains there was equal potential for both sides to win.

It just fell out in a manner that did not favor HCRealms' style Town.

But that HCR Town is intrinsically flawed in my opinion.

Sign me up, if you will have me!

Apparently arguing about old games attracts players.

Doom, you got any problems with my old games?

(Not that you could!)

[That's not true, I've had my share of balancing issues]

Doomsie! Add Keds and Ignatz!

So we need 4 more players...

Why hasn't Iceman signed up yet? Someone needs to kill off Hatut Zeraze in one of his games, I like that guy, he should be in my game.