I think you're being to much of a buttet ball..or to critical. If someone is able to bring proof then yea but saying "yo man you can't kill my superman with katanas exploit weakness"...why.."I got an email man...I got an email" show me. "Here dog I copied it as a text msg" show me the email not copy paste. "I ain't gots no signalz" fine tyen give me your email and password (trolololo)..

All joking aside. If I'm shown proof then I'm fine but a simple I got an e-mail isn't good enough.

But would it also not be drawn from Iron Pharaoh too?


XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXPXXXXXX
XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
XXXXXXXFXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX

So the above would be the area that Iron Pharaoh would hit with his Pulse Wave with 9 Range (halved to 5)

Neither the Rulebook nor PG do that. It's exclusively in the CTR.

Official documentation never once references hcrealms.


Nowhere does it say that forum posts are more legitimate than emails, or that emails should be treated any differently. All it says is that forum posts are legitimate communication. Clearly, so is email.

This is 100% correct. It doesn't say that forum posts are the only place to get rules information. It just says that it's also a place to get rules confirmation. Nowhere does it say that you can't get rules information from emails. Emails are perfectly valid forms of rules communications.

I agree with Iron Pharaoh thoughts. Makes sense.

I do not agree with Copycat thoughts.
If you can Mind Control a similar Unique or another Prime,
you should be able to take them with Copycat.
Even though it can last for awhile, Copycat's "switch" should still be considered temporary.


And if somebody has ruled that Fantomex Pulse Waving thru EVA kills it,
I do not agree with that ruling.
(although it wouldn't be the first time)

Please show me where it states that emails can supersede the written rules documentation.

You cannot because it does not say that and it never will. The "ruling" that someone posted here is in direct contradiction of the written rules. It is not a clarification on how something is to be used it is a direct contradiction. As such it is not a legitimate ruling per the rules documents themselves even if you want to make that false claim that email = forum post (which again the rules documentation does not support).

Yes. To one person. Not to the masses.

Agreed that that's a problem.

That is hugely subject to interpretation though.

Saying that Copycat can't steal a Prime doesn't contradict anything, unless you can quote the rulebook page that says explicitly that the limitation on Primes in only ever relevant for force construction. Since that is not anywhere written in the rulebook, there is nothing out of place with that being made as a "clarification" rather than a "rules change."

Ultimately, email-only is a terrible system. But trying to leverage the email-only to something less than forum posts in ridiculous. They are fully equivalent in terms of rules weight, and only different in terms of accessibility...or lack thereof.

Please show me where it states that they don't.

Just to add to the discussion, got my email back from Heroclix Rules:

Q: Can iron pharaoh use pulse wave through his falcon if he is granted it somehow?

A: Yes

It's interesting when you read through the Area of Effect rules again, and then the Pulse Wave rule. Pulse Wave does not specify that Area of Effect is in fact centered around the attacking character. I could read it that I make a Ranged Combat Attack (if doesn't specify that I need to make an attack roll - nor that that attack is considered a Ranged attack). 'Each hit character' is the only thing telling me that I'm actually making an attack here.

In the absence of Pulse Wave telling me that the Area of Effect is actually centered around the attacking character, I could use Pulse Wave where ever I could legally count my Range from (since I draw lines of fire to everything within that half range.)

The Falcon lets me draw lines of fire from it.
It lets me count my Range from it.
Therefore, I can center my Area of Effect around the Falcon.
However, the Range through the Falcon is 3, so it will be locked at 2 if Pulse Waving from the Falcon's square.
From Iron Pharaoh's square is remains a range of 9, locked to 5 for Pulse Wave.
You could argue that the Falcon's max Range of 3, isn't a 'Range of 3', but more that no Range can be counted beyond 3. So, Iron Pharaoh could Pulse Wave with an area of effect of 5, but from the Falcon's square it is reduced to 3.

An e-mail would qualify as an on-line post.

Dragon, go home and be a family man.

post - (verb) display (a notice) in a public place.