I can't believe I didn't recognize myself in the N2 write-up....

I don't believe that's a PGO killing people last Night because then Gfish would be alive as he didn't target the PGO. So that would mean a partner or someone who took over for DF.

Vote Count:

Colonialbob (1): Silver Lantern

CBob's vote is with Rokk

With 8 players, 5 is a majority.

The mod is going to bed. Play relatively nice and I'll post an updated count in the morning. On the off chance majority is reached while I'm asleep, the phase would officially end at that point in time.

I shouldn't have mentioned I failed so early in the day.

I wish Cbob had better targets, but he did comment about one or two of them, so that's a help. Definitely gfish. And did he out Gir as neutral? Or did Gir say that himself?

Read the headache inducing N2 quandary I typed earlier. As for N3, a BD or a MD had to have something to do with Quebbs' death.

(Ok. Now I'm second guessing myself as to whether I used the RB or the MD Nexus N2. I'm pretty certain it was the MD but that's the same timeframe and order of powers I used over in gfish's Birdman game so now I'm paranoid I'm confusing the two. Doubtful as I said my actions after each Nite and I don't think I would have forgotten that soon. Only reason I would have hesitated a MD Nexus on N2 was concern of messing Truff's results if she was watching over the Vig. Then again I figured her and I would be married and I could fill her in by Mason contact.)

Gir outted himself as Neutral. His actions were so lousy I know I debated if he was scum or Neutral. It was only when someone else I thought was scum - IR - talked so definitively about Gir's Neutrality I felt that was likely true.

Little surprised CBob didn't confirm so, if we wanted, we could have tried to lynch someone else (though Gir was basically acting Mafia Friendly so still feel it was a good lynch).

However, I feel CBob is on the up-and-up especially with that write-up appearance.

That's why I was trying to get Gira's info as to if he was messed with in order to see the chain of events and where I mentioned you "fibbing" and you correcting that.

Then last phase, I asked Sir Bob how his night was to see if he may have been messed with.

hmmm... Not sure if I buy the cop claim. Want to hear from JoH.

Would be awesome if Morph has some results from last night too.

What about the Cop claim is bugging you, SL? Not contesting you. Actually trying to keep an open mind instead of just going, "He was certain I was Town and we appeared in a write-up together." as that mindset backfires on me too often so trying to improve.

I can't believe it either! And yeah, duh, should have realized that. I was trying to post my thoughts real quick before bed and didn't really read who died to the explosion.

I think my targets were fine (although I'm a little grumpy about all of them except Rokk being dead).

Gfish was (semi) random N1.
Rokk was because of his and JoH's back and forth. JoH was pinging me more at first, but then grizzz flipped town, so I wanted to make sure Rokk was on the up and up.
Girathon was N3 because he was so quiet (see erage's list, for example).
Ice was N4 because I couldn't get a great read on him, and (as discussed) I figured I_R was climbing the ranks of vig targets. Turns out I was right.

Didn't really feel like it was worth outing myself as cop to save a neutral who was (at the minimum) not helping the town. I did say I thought the lynch was mostly a waste of time though.

Reads (keeping in mind I haven't gone over anything in fine detail)

1. JoH - 4/5 town (only concern is whether he was a scum masoned to town, but I_R's labeling of him or rokk as scum makes me trust him)
2. Rokk - 5/5 town (copped and fighting demons in write-upb)
6. Colonialbob - 5/5 town
7. Morphy - 2/5 town (doesn't make sense for mafia (or his partner) to out the sk)
9. RenegadeRoy - 2/5 mafia (have a feeling this was a fake claim)
15. Silver Lantern - 5/5 town (2 mafia kills last night prove that pretty well, even if I don't understand the Pax hit)
16. Truffle Shuffle - 2/5 town (got grizzz lynched, but I don't think that was a scum play)
18. eternalrage - ???? Numbers say probably up to no good

I'm also confused why a second SK would target gfish... He's a neutral doubler. What's the point?

Maybe a PGO-maker?

@ truff: I wish I was around more too. My schedule has been really unpredictable recently.
@ Silver: I have nothing today, I failed last night.

I'm going to be spotty between now and about 11 central due to work. Should be around the rest of the day though.

@ColonBob: Your reason for Copping me doesn't match events. You said you Copped me on N2. The situation with me and JoH didn't happen until the day after and the following Nite I appear to have been JK'ed. After that Nite is when you defended me, meaning you may have Copped me on N2 but unless you can view future phases it wasn't for the reason you stated.

Now I have to admit to being more open to doubt as it feels you came up with a narrative to justify targets and goofed.