And it reads like the same person ran you off and killed Charles, if that was the case.

An undoctorable kill, maybe?

I targetted Sigdr, since he was really pushing the 'psychiatrists are TEH MAFIA!' thing, which I knew was false. But he got killed, so that was a waste of a night action on my part.

The deal with the knife: Check my writeup in the Arkham Horror Wiki. The knife was used to kill one of my patients, I'm trying to find out who it belongs to. Given the nature of the boardgame, there's no 'set answer' to who owns it -- it's just an excuse to get me into the game.

I have reason to believe Adam on his claim. Besides it does appear we do still have a doctor running around and no one else is claiming dr so that seems to at least for the time being support Adam being who he said.

Well, since you aren't lying about targeting him, we're good. For now.

I'll try to contain my warm fuzzy feeling.

So, anyway... it's day 5. Who hasn't been posting but hasn't been replaced yet?

Looking at the list, it seems like most have been pretty consistent with posting.

I don't recognize too many on the list that haven't posted in awhile.

4 nights in and three janitored deaths...meaning whatever night it didn't happen a kill failed. I tried to target Bob last night but my action failed :-/.

Hrm. Not entirely convinced, but for now I'll Remove Vote.

Because after the Two-Face / JK'er fiasco it would be easy to try and use that as "evidence" of two Doctors.

Don't necessarily feel that's the way to push today, but everyone keeps asking "Why would he?" and I felt the obvious was being skipped: because it would be such an obvious blunder folks would feel it wasn't a blunder.

Did you get a message of failure?

You think he might be hiding in plain sight?

Nope, no message of failure.

Phoenixfire hasn't been active in a while, at least it seemed to me I didn't know he was in this game until I looked at the list (that Leeloo avie is pretty memorable), I checked up on it, says almost 10 days since his last post, could be looking at it wrong but without going through 56 pages of text, thats just the feeling I've gotten. To be fair according to his stats he hasn't been active anywhere on the forum in 10 days so who knows if it really means anything.

Pretty confident Adam isn't mafia, even with Rokk's wierd "I played bad on purpose to make you think I was good" logic.

Also, do we have any idea on the theme of the Mafia. I don't know any of the characters, granted I have a slim grasp of the Lovecraft side of it, things t hat aren't in the game I'm really kind of lost. As it seems that there are Lovecrafts on the good side and ones on the bad side, but I don't know if there is a specific theme among the Mafia.

At this point I'm thinking two mafias anyway.