Here's my notes on vote history:

Red = confirmed mafia
blue = town
green = neutral or likely town.

Day 1 lynch: NAES/Man-thing
JackofHearts: Truffle
Naes: JoH, Malakim, MBauers, Pax, Get_1, Ghosta, TVK, Darq, Rokk, Morph33, ABF, Anonym0use, Stranger, Nifty, Hatut, Kontrol
No Lynch: Maniac

Day 2 Lynch - no lynch (day ended prematurely)
Truffle: H&C, MBauers, ABF, Maniac, Iceman, HZ, Darq, Stranger, Malakim, ViciousBuddah, Shadow40

Havok&Chaos: Kontrol, Get_1, Tyroman

Hatut Zeraze: Wade

Day 3: no lynch (no majority reached)

Havok&Chaos: MBauers, Wade, Kontrol, VicousBuddah, Coyote, TVK, tyroman, ghosta, Pax, Anony

Ouchmaker: Hatut, Rokk, Mal, ghosta

Pax: Get_1, Iceman, coyotejack, Maniac

Day 4: No Lynch (truffle escaped)
Lynch Tally

Truffle: Anony, Pax, TVK, JoH, MorphD, Kontrol, Shadow40, Stranger, Kedryn, Wade, Malakim, Ghosta, ViciousBuddah

Havoc&Chaos: Truffle, Tyroman

Day 4 continued:
Lynch Tally - Wade escapes a lynch.

Havoc&Chaos: HZ, TVK

WadeWilson: MBauers, Maniac, Kontrol, Anonym0use, ViciousBuddah, Malakim, Stranger, Pax, Shadow, JoH, Kedryn, MorphD, Tyroman

JackofHearts: WadeWilson

ViciousBuddah: Coyote


Day 5: Wade is finally lynched. WadeWilson is dead. He was Lilith, the Mother of Demons

WadeWilson: Coyote, Anonym0use, Pax, Ghosta, Shadow, MorphD, Michigan, Malakim, ViciousBuddah, JoH, MBauers, Kedryn

ViciousBuddah: Maniac, Tyroman, HZ


Day 6: Wasted on VB:
Lynch Vote Tally .....ViciousBuddah is dead. He was Daniel Ketch. Town/Good.

ViciousBuddah: MBauers, Pax, HZ, TVK, Coyote, Carlos, Michigan, MorphD, Stranger, Maniac, Tyroman

CarlosMucha: Ouchmaker, ViciousBuddah


MBauers: Anonym0use

Well, other then H&C looking guilty, and a healthy distrust of ABF and Mr. Stranger, I got nothing. So you if you have a solid lead

Here's the surviving players that remain unknowns in my notes:

Using vote history I have tried to piece together a few possible paths.

5) TheVagrantKing - voted Naes, truffle, VB & H&C
6) Kedryn - voted Wade & Truffles the day they both escaped a lynch - voted Wade the following day.
7) PaxZRake Voted VB, Wade, Wade & Truffle, H&C, NAES. Of note is that 4 people voted for him day 3, all town or neutral.
8) Michigan - voted vb and wade - horrible vote record.
13) ABF - votes Naes and truffles - horrible voted record
14) Tyroman - votes VB, Wade, & pushes a lot to vote H&C.
18) Mr. Stranger - Naes, truffle, wade, and VB
20) Havok&Chaos - never voted?
23) Ouchmaker - has only voted once - for Carlos AFAIK.
24) MBauers highly likely that he's mafia or a neutral. Voted for everyone except Truffle shuffle and wade wilson on the day that both Truffle Shuffle and Wade Wilson escaped a lynch.
25) CarlosMucha highly likely that he's mafia. Voted only for Viciousbuddah.
27) Hatut Z - Like mbauers he didn't vote Truffle shuffle and wade wilson on the day that both Truffle Shuffle and Wade Wilson escaped a lynch. wade threw a vote on Hatut early in the game, which makes me think he may not be scum.
29) Ghosta - voted Naes, wade, and ouchmaker - inconclusive data at this time.

In any event, lynching H&C today will likely give us more detail. If he's town, Tyroman may be very suspect. If he's scum, then it helps clear a lot of doubt.

Lynch Havokandchaos

Judging by some vote records I think it's highly likely this game was lost to town apathy. We'll see.

I can vouch for Hatut_Zerase, he's town.

Lynch Vote Tally


H&C: Stranger, Tyro, ViciousBuddah, MBauers, Maniac, Darq, Kedryn, Coyote, Anonym0use


10 votes are required for majority.

On your list, I would tend to think Carlos, ABF are two of our most likely subjects. Both are being very very quiet.

Mbauers and Ouchmaker could also be likely suspects.

How much time do we have left? I could be persuaded to switch to one of them.

Not only is this wrong, but your reasoning is ridiculous.

1) Truffle Shuffle was lynched so fast that she was already gone by the time I got online. Had I been online, I wouldn't have voted right away because I would have told everyone else to slow the hell down so we could strategize more.

2) I voted for Wade Wilson when he was lynched the first time because I didn't believe his claim. I was one of the first few people to vote for him, actually IIRC.

3) I didn't vote for Wade right away the second time (after he was confirmed mafia) because I thought he could easily be vig killed and we could pressure someone else.

How stupid do you think I am that I would be scum and not vote for outted scum? Give me some credit man.

You act like you're an investigator, but one night you forget to send in a target and now I'm supposed to believe that you DIDN'T investigate me last night? You post at the end of the thread how I must be scum, yet you don't investigate me and then you vote to lynch H&C? What have you done that clears you?

I can't believe I wasn't silenced last night. I thought for sure the scum would have framed me by now.

mouse thanks for your work and to alievate any doubts i'm in the write up in n3:

[Quote:] Night Three

In diverse locations six different mystics cast a diverse assortment of spells. One saved a life. One stopped a murder. One unwittingly aided the enemy. One pierced the veil between life and death, working dangerous and delicate magiks. One took a chance on who to trust. [/quote]
i now firmly believe i stopped a murder since i was blocking H&C. you'll notice if you look a back over the last couple of nites, the dwarf doesn't appear in the write ups. last nite my block failed and look there he is again. draw your own conclusions but i feel ive been doing a good thing.

I'm not Mafia guys, I'm neutral.

Just want to say that I can vouch for her as well.

To the same degree I can also vouch for mbauers.

Mbauers - sorry if my post is overly accusatory. I'm a lot paranoid right now. To answer your question, I handed truffles to us, beyond a shadow of a doubt. I said she was lying and proved that she was not Raydar (sp?).

My pseduo-inflamitory post has done what I meant it to - get people talking. Something we needed desperately to do. In the few posts that followed we have:

Maniac clearing HZ
tyro pointing himself out in the write-up
Carlos claiming neutral
Ouchmaker vouching Mbauers and HZ.

If that's all true it leaves Pax, ABF and MJ24 looking shady.

5) TheVagrantKing - voted Naes, truffle, VB & H&C
6) Kedryn - voted Wade & Truffles the day they both escaped a lynch - voted Wade the following day.
7) PaxZRake Voted VB, Wade, Wade & Truffle, H&C, NAES. Of note is that 4 people voted for him day 3, all town or neutral.
8) Michigan - voted vb and wade - horrible vote record.
13) ABF - votes Naes and truffles - horrible voted record
18) Mr. Stranger - Naes, truffle, wade, and VB
20) Havok&Chaos - never voted?
29) Ghosta - voted Naes, wade, and ouchmaker - inconclusive data at this time.

Aside: I'm trying to find Midnight sons in a collected edition, was it ever released in trade?

Thanks!

As I'm feeling a bit ill...

For good or bad:

Lynch: Havok&Chaos

Of course if you have a solid claim mbauers, you shouldn't fear to throw it out there, y'know - being marked for death and all.

I simply assumed HZ, Ouch, and mbauers were simply claiming to be in a mason group. My notes are a bit outdated though...