I sort of did the first night... I thought it was an actual mafia reference, sort of like being "rubbed out", or "sleeping with the fishes". Shows what I know...

TBB, you gotta post the results!

I did already. Like, right after the game ended.

What powers could I have received if I chose Bulbasaur or Squirtle?

I didn't have it all planned out.

I knew that the starter level would have the same power (scratched or tackled), Ivysaur would have Leech Seed, which would let you permanently steal a vote, and Wartortle would have withdraw, which would give you some immunity.