Adam is eager to throw darkstone under the bus if the opportunity presents itself. Noted.

I think this is a ranked town-to-scum list. Roy is near the bottom, joh is right in the middle. Darkstone a spot below Roy (MP/JJJ is the only more suspicious player, apparently) and killingjoke is the second strongest townie read he has despite also not acknowledging his vig claim in a meaningful way. This a common theme among the dead bad guys.

We're onto Day 4 now. jackofheart's came out with a joint suspicion (as we all did) against Adamical and Immortal_Raven. killingjoke promptly hopped right on... the case against Immportal_Raven. Completely ignoring that adamical is also a person of interest.

Question(s) for colonialbob or any regular player here:
How do mafia team kills work? Is there typically one player assigned to do the killing each night? Is it a joint team kill? Does the killer alternate per night?

shaking my head at this parenthetical.

This is in response to Jay asking kj who he's most suspicious of. I read this post like this:
"adamical is suspicious, but here's all the reasons we should lynch Immortal_Raven."

My eyes are starting to shut themselves, so I need to cut myself off now.
An observation I've begun to make as I'm looking back over the thread is that Darkstone appears very relaxed about everything in the game and nonchalant about his night actions (rolling dice to pick his night 3 targets, acting mostly out of self-protection). I am inclined to say this is a decent look, but again, it's not something I'm willing to let him off the hook for. I might have tunnel-vision turned on, but I've come out of this feeling worse about killingjoke and better about darkstone.

change vote killingjoke

I have another busy day tomorrow but I hope I'll be able to do a little more work in here myself. And even if I can't, I hope that you all can. We're so close to winning this thing I can taste it. Let's get it done.

I do not like that killingjoke takes credit for being the "first to vote adam". As I just spent some time highlighting, killingjoke seemed more focused on steering the lynch away from adam the day he was lynched until his fate became inevitable.
I've not looked at his jackofhearts claim either. But I will ask this question for kj: if you were so confident about these suspects so as to offer the "first votes" for them on the days where they were lynched, why not just shoot them at night?

I am off to sleep now. I still want to dig up IR's Night 2 target. Darkstone's recent point against kj's actions from that night and subsequent day are too obvious to be overlooked. He claims to be the vigilante and yet his only kill in the game comes from a night where there was no other kill, and we seem to have no evidence to suggest that the mafia kill was prevented in any way that night. I need killingjoke to explain how that's not damning.
And then I need him to present a big juicy case against darkstone. Because that's what the holidays are for.

I finally figured out how to search the thread just as I was heading off. Alright cool. So now we know that Immortal_Raven, the only town player capable of preventing a scum kill in this game, was on Silver Lantern Night 2. Any reason we should not be lynching killingjoke today? Also any reason we didn't catch this sooner?

Sorry for making these last 2 pages all mine. This old timer does ramble on.

Typically the way it works is that one member of the mafia performs the kill as their night action instead of using their regular Power. There are exceptions to this, but they are rare.

I realize you might be tired, so let's go with that, but that is completely false. I claimed to kill BOTH DestructoBoy as well as Immortal_Raven. My judgement has been pretty off this game and I have been playing fairly lazily. Also, if Darkstone wants to throw out hypothetical situations and assumptions, I will do the same:

We see after N2 a lot of Mafia interaction. Roy claims that he Tracks Adamical, in which he finds that Adamical Jailkeeps Darkstone. Darkstone claimed that he Busdrove himself and Sloonei, which is supposedly the reason that JJJ receives a town read from his cop result on Darkstone.

I believe adam was simply backing up Darkstone's claim of "being messed with" on N2. That should have allowed JJJ to receive the Town copping on DS that night (if we are going under the assumption that the jailkeep does not block any night actions from happening). There seems to be a lot of collusion from mafia regarding that evening. Roy backing up adam, adam saying that he targeted DS, and JoH even supports Roy's claim.

I'm sorry I am not posting any quotes or direct references, but Sloonei, I encourage you to look back between N2 and the end of D4 to see what transpired and the evidence from SilverLantern and JJJ. I will post direct references after work.

My results were that I failed N2.

Those didn't happen on the same. N2 was when I was jail kept, N3 was when I swapped with Sloonei.

You are correct though, you did kill I_R. On a night when their was Also no mafia kill.

If you go by the write ups, Dboys kill involved a whip. The I_R kill involved being killed by horses. Last night's kill also involved horses.

This is tough. You are both raising good points. I still feel like Darkstone is the last mafia. I am just going to go with my gut on this one and say Vote Darkstone.

I'll try to keep an eye on the thread at work today and will be back on in about 9 hours.