Holy carp! I thought I was stepping in to a no win situation! I was surprised we made it as far as we did, though we got lucky by figuring out who J-pop was and using him for two kills a night.

I decided after modding JLA:Detroit, that a controlled misdirector was too powerful, and this game may have backed up the point.

Good game all!

Wow I thought with the way Mousie was going after his own teammates i was sure one us would have been lynched for sure( I know it was strategy but I had to PM the mod to make sure you actually replaced Thawmus not just had a new role as I was convinced Sinestro had gone good for awhile)
Well congrats to my fellow mafiaoso and good game to all

For all I knew you were protecting a mafia buddy. I was shocked when he came up neutral. I basically told the town that if he was not mafia they could lynch me the following day. Good thing no one took me up on it.

There was a certain element to be an outed mafiaoso that I wanted to play on, and... I think it kinda worked. I was hoping that by picking fights with some of my teammates it would misdirect attention away from them and toward the town.

I agree with Thawmus though, some of the least fun I've had is in games where the head mafia don can't be lynched until X condition occurs. It's okay in Epic games (LotR, CoIE) where the whole shebang is at stake, but in random games (I believe I was frustarted to no end with Ignatz in Watchmen mafia) that I lost hope, and lost interest in the game.

Sweet. We won.

Yeah but the problem is I wasnt sure if everyone belived you were mafia as otherwise why were all the votes going towards us lol

Yeah I think it was ULT Spidey where I got exteremly frustared knowing who Kingpin and Norman were and being able to do nothing about it. I dont mind if you have a power that protects you once (like stopping a lynch but unlynchable ( and the way it was worded it wasnt till the mafia was gone it was just permenant so short of a Sk or vig Sinestro was immortal

One reason I had an unlynchable don (and with one night immunity) was that there was only one Mafia, and a small-ish one at that.

As far as the redirector thing-- I'm on the fence. If j-pop had been more forthright after he was first used that way, or if he refrained from killing after that, it would have been different. In my view, that was a critical mistake on his part.

Define "critical mistake"

I am of the opinion that it was critically awesome.
Also, to be fair, I was mind controlling a doctor into you guys for the longest time.

*Ahem*

"Go find Carol Ferris. That's it. No powers for now."

"Oh sorry, Carol died on Night 1."


Yeah, you're a terrible judge of me. Then again, I don't think anyone can figure out any of my play patterns because I am fairly schizo. Unpredictable. Whichever.

But you were half right in the beginning. I was a serial killer who got a kill before the day that I was lynched. Boo!

Me turning up as a Neutral was really the worst case scenario for everyone. It cleared no one and just made everybody look suspicious. That's me...always finding a way to throw a wrench in things!


...I like how you made your mafia frustration-kill anonym0use the night immediately following. That was fun.

nah. Someone just killed you that night.
Then MSU (previously killed) replaced someone. And then you (also previously killed) replaced another player.

All in all, not cool. Players who have been in that game should not be allowed back in. Even if they did nothing else, they have knowledge of at least one other role that used to be in the game.











Also, once again, this game descended into a dirty dirty mess. Games that I participate in actively tend to do that. To everyone: I'm sorry for that.

I kept waiting for that to payoff for the town, but it never did.

It was still funny, you guys were convinced he was a roleblocker or something.

Yeah, I'm not going to let people back in again. The peple let in didn't have any knowledge that woudl help them, but clearly feelings and perceptions played a huge part.

He was a roleblocker...

You changed his role post-mortem!

It wasn't a vendetta Thawmus! It was the way you were reacting on Day 2! That is why i went after you! It was honestly when you got all "upset" when I came up as Town and wanted to go after the other person. That is when I knew you were "acting" since you didn't just come in and say "whoops, mah bad!" you went after the other guy. It was too obvious!

I was extremely inactive, and I'm sorry for that. Real life took over, and prevented me from being here.

But hooray scum!

On unlynchables, I don't mind town ones.