The main reason you're going to get lynched is because you've told us nothing about you. Your role, your character, what you do, none of it. You're a big question mark.

So, if you have nothing....did Mal just forget to send you a role, or something?

Well Thawmus - I don't do anything. No night action, no cool powers, nothing. And with what I looked up about my character on wiki - there's no reason I can see for me not to have one. Ergo, it's pointless to RC, as if I with no knowledge of Bioware games wouldn't believe it, I don't expect anyone else to.

Day 1 - no lynch JackA pressured a bit.

Day 2 - mb starts on JackA. JoH votes maj. Towards end of day Rokk focuses on JackA lack of lync for two days.

Day 3 - Quebs starts on Maj. Rokk keeps on JackA because of lack of votes for two days in a row. Thaw argues against it. Maj is lynched.

Day 4 - Pressure on Kit. She gives some info. I review Day 3 lynch and vote Hail. Further review change vote to Tyro. Rokk helps push Tyro. JackA votes Wade. Thawmus gets mad about Tyro lynch.

Day 5 - Rokk starts on JoH (hail votes JoH, Normal votes JoH). Darq suggests Thaw and Hail says better targets in JoH or Wade. JoH clams and votes Wade. Reminder of misdirection and JoH changes to Hail. Rokk votes Hail. I vote Hail. Hail screws the pooch on his claiming. Normal votes Hail. Keds votes Hail.

Day 6 - Arguments about JoH. Votes against him. He claims. I vote Keds. JoH starts on JackA. Normal doesn't like JoH's claim. Thaw doesn't like the JackA train. JackA lynched.

Day 7 - Kit lynched.

*********************
JoH is NOT mafia. Your scenario where he would throw that many under the bus ... not buying it. If anything, he could be the SK. So that's still an option. Also, I don't know what your problem is with Rokk, but as far as I can tell his only mistake was thinking JackA could be Dark Sonic. He was right to push on JackA and his initial reason was because the votes went no where 2 days in a row, and then 3 days in a row. His reasoning for trusting JoH, via the Hail lynch, was sound. And Normal agreed that would be the case the day Hail was lynched, and then the next day Normal seemed to forget that. So those arguments were also sound.

As I can see it the only huge mistake the town has made so far is Kit's lynch. And if I had removed my vote sooner and reviewed the thread I think I would have pushed for Keds instead of her. Very disappointed in myself for that one, since I'm the double voter. Should have been more responsible.

Thawmus, the fact that you "now have a kill power" makes me more suspicous of you. It's a good way to explain away kills. Why, exactly, did you gain a kill power? Without quoting, you need to explain the reasoning on that. If it should be apparent because of who you are, remember I don't know the source.

So, JoH could be SK.
Normal, could be mafia or SK.
Thawmus, could be mafia or SK. Though with his admittance of neutral from beginning, more likely SK.

Again, Keds autopsy will shed light on JoH. If Keds is mafia, JoH could still be SK. If Keds is neutral and seems like SK, that clear JoH 100% for me.

Lame. Not buying it.

No one ever does buy my RC's. Which is why I don't usually bother - it never matters.

But that wasn't even a roleclaim. That was nothing. What's to believe ... that you have no power? You're not even going to let us try to see the reasoning, because conveniently, you wouldn't even believe it.

In all honesty, I figure this game is only still going on because there's a chance the mafia might hit which ever townie Pax isn't protecting.

I'd like to hear JoH's thoughts on things. So I'll hold onto my vote a while longer.

And I almost forgot.

I'm not saying JoH is mafia. However, that is one of the only remaining scenarios for me. See it from my perspective, if only for a moment. It's one of only two conclusions I can possibly draw anymore.

However, there is no way JoH is the SK. He could not pass that off as being the cop. There is a variation on the SK, that I got myself one time, that could be used for copping, but you wouldn't be able to confirm townies with it.

As for Rokk, again, it's a quibble that's not for public spewing. Suffice to say, I like the guy, so let's not make it into a "Thawmus hates Rokk, wtf is his deal?" discussion.

I disagreed with a lot of his reasoning and logic. Frankly, despite the results, it was still pretty flawed. Because 11-13 people didn't feel Jack was worth a vote, he was mafia? I'm all for pointing out when trains run into turbulence, but that was not turbulence. Your train had no coal to begin with.

Fontlebottom, in the game, debates and insults you. Then, when you beat him in the debate, he duels you with Mirabelle, his big ol' powdergun.

My debate and insulting of the Mafia is done. Now Mirabelle's just gonna wax what's left.

Well, at least we now have a blueprint for how to gain your trust. "Lead lynches on fellow mafia members."

I might also add that Shel pointed this out repeatedly, until JoH led a lynch against her.

I've only been in a game with him twice now, and he was like this before, as well. He with-holds basic information, and then claims he couldn't have done anything, rather than pay our intelligence any respect.

I don't understand your reasoning about how JoH couldn't possibly be the SK. None of his coppings have panned out. Which is why I'm still so suspicous of him.

This is true, Thawmus - but, in this specific instance, it would be beneficial to both the mafia and the town to lynch me.

And, it's actually because I respect your intelligence that I'm not really trying to not get lynched.

I'm not making into a Thawmus hates Rokk discussion, so really, please don't go in that direction.

Okay, so any time we can't get pressure on someone, for 2 to 3 days in a row, we should just ignore that. Okay. Got it.

As for your comment about having my number about how to get me to trust you, whatever. At some point you have to make a decision or you get no where.

omg Thawmus totally hate Rokk!