It's very possible AFR is lying about targeting two people and that he was digging for power claims.

Yeah, let's assume that. Then they could both be telling the truth. Darkstone's claim matches the Gangles writeup.

But if we don't assume that then what?

Darkstone was misdirected/is lying? Probably not.
Af is lying? Why? He's in the writeup?

Yeah but I keep coming back to "Gangles is in the writeup arresting Grinner."

What possible reason could he have to lie? How could Gangles be bad in this situation?

He's in the writeup removing someone from the game, if we're assuming he's Gangles. He might not want to lay claim to that power since, y'know, he is claiming other powers.

Wait, okay, I see your point as AF is claiming power-copier.

*sigh* now that all that reading's over...

Because I don't have as many positive reads as everyone else, and so I'm just like, "Let's see, who haven't I targeted that at any point in time did something I liked...Ooh, this guy ran my second favorite favorite mafia series! That's good enough for now!"

For real, my night 1 targeting patterns last for, like, four to five night phases.

I mean, next time, if you want, I'd totally just let a bunch of roleblockers destroy your plans, if that's what you're looking for

You know who would be really great at not dying against these animals, or any threat in general? Someone who's half Lobo, half Deadpool. That's right, send in the immortal guy who stopped caring a long time ago and just kills for money now! He'd be perfect!

Not sure, it's a good point. Afr could be lying to dodge the "well you killed someone" bullet. A smarter claim in that instance would've been vig TBH...

Gangles could be the "shell" here. Could just as easily be a clone? Or he's the traitor (we all know Gangles is more about Gangles than teamwork, wouldn't be a stretch for him to sell out to Sineater)

@DB

You should know who three Leaguers and the doctor are, even if you don't believe any of the claimed info gatherers.



Vlad = SKer

IR, DB as mafia?

Honestly... no positive reads so you go with a complete random? Jack has claimed Lamplighter. That's where I would go until proven otherwise. Who else have you targeted?

Ninja'd by Jack :P

Yeah, Jack, those reads are lookin' good to me.

TBH, I got distracted when I was on the computer for the closing of N2 and...totally spaced sending an action for that night...

targeted Grinner night 1. Seems like a good idea to be on the good side of the player I live with

EVENT ANSWER:

The Queen has got to check herself before she wrecks her people. The first response to the appearance of animals does NOT have to be hunters. That's the easy way out, for those not concerned with justice and civilization, at least. They have appeared, but the only people doing any threatening were the hunters.

The Queen wants an exploratory party formed, to study these animals and discover what makes them so strange, what brought them here, and if they are intelligent enough to be reasoned with and accepted into Kronn as equals. Unless it turns out that they are Sineater bastards.

Actually, DB called GFish on his character claim.

The one reason I'm not 100% sold on good Af is LC's results on him as Dreamus. There were enough misdirects running around and iirc, the mafia didn't know LC's power last night and also most people thought he was town. Not likely misdirected.

Whoa, whoa, WHOA! That was kind of quick for such a strong decision! Just because I don't target some specific people, that's crossing the line from oblivious player to straight-up bad guy?

Also, of ALL the people to ask if my targeting is scummy, you ask the guy I targeted with s positive power? If I were scum, that would probably mean he is, too. Why would he throw me under the bus?

^^^^^ that second part is hypothetical, of course.

+1

What if Frankenjustice is some sort of mafia frame-up job? That's what I keep coming back to since he's not in the player list. But that's still a weird interaction with gfish. Like, the fact that Frankenjustice presumably killed Flow and died with Ebb's lynch is just too much coincidence for me to swallow.

I can totally buy DB/IR mafia. I think DB is often clueless like a fox.