Any idea who the SK is? I don't see much in the way of description. Is Sylar supposed to work that way? Can someone link the role or tell me the game he's from? Also, I recall a game where the SK was some kind of evil force and not actually a being. That ring a bell for anyone?

I'm perusing roles for both the mafia don and the SK since I'm inclined to think RP is Dr. Horrible.

What do we think of Basil Fawlty for the Don? He was a busdriver and the unofficial Don for the Fawlty towers mafia. Could explain some of the things going on.

I don't think you understand how these games work very well. And I apologize if this comes off with a condescending tone as that is not my intent. But it isn't anyone's job to figure that out and nobody cares to. Your refusal to claim is only seen as a scum tactic of trying to hide, because real townies understand the importance of claiming when it will help townies concentrate on the real threats.

Sylar was masoned with a townie. I forget which game he was from.

I find his presence unlikely since Secret Bear was also masoned in the Care Bears game. I figure if Secret Bear suspected Sylar, he would have outed himself to take Sylar down. That and Mags' overly paranoid ghost-write make me think it's not Sylar.

The only common theme for the SK that I can see is blood, always spreading. No noises mentioned so I would guess a shiv or a knife.

And why was it suggested that Sylar is the SK other than Mags being overly paranoid? He must have had a reason.

The fact that IR was dragged the night with only an SK kill pretty much clears him as not the SK imo.

I think I understand them just fine, thanks.

He might be claiming Mr. hitler.

It's pretty clear he's claiming scum. Hitler has no reason not to claim.

Mr. Hitler cannot claim, right? He is not allowed to by role. But then again, Mr. Hitler is a janitoring PGO, so secret bear should not have survived the copping.

Oh you say that now....

Actually, Hitler is not allowed to claim.


I just checked through the roles and I'm at a loss. There are no SKs that fit the "and then there was blood" motif. Maybe punisher from my Hulk Clix game, but then Ghost Rider would be here and the kills would look different on alternating nights.

I did not realize that Hitler couldn't claim. I always hate roles with that restriction. They violate did process.

That is a possibility I suppose.

Double check all neutral roles if you can IR. maybe one was altered.

No one remembers a game where a force of evil like a dark cloud or something was making the kills?

Pepperidge Farm remembers.

Yeah, those restrictions are the trade-off for being a neutral, non-SK. Too easy to skate as a neutral so you gotta throw some sort of curveball as a mod. Except for with SKs. I overpower those guys way too much as a mod.

If anyone else has time to dive through and look for a SK, be my guest. I admit Sylar could be here but you figure Secret Bear would have outed him by now. Unless of course we have two sets of masons since I doubt Secret Bear who has given us gold is that dumb.