This is akin to a Role Cop finding the SK on N1 and not saying anything or an Alignment Cop not outting Mafia. Considering you would've stopped the Cult in its' tracks immediately on Day 2...

why present it now and not at the beginning of the day phase?

Sorry, but this just seems all too convenient....I have seen plays like this before. I have orchestrated played like this before.

Kness has three votes on him - mine, disco, and Rokk. You guys panic and decide that you are gonna "exonerate" him through your cult finding, using Ouch as your set up.

You copped him on night one as cult, you didn't want the Cult SKer on you but if you had him lynched on day 2, there would be no cult. No cult Sker. Yo uwould have been protected during the night. I don't understand why you would keep this until NOW. Except to protect your cult friend, Kness.

It doesn't make sense.....

Oh, and as for me not voting for Satu, I thought it should have been pretty obvious to not vote for him. He had been claiming "bomb" for about full day, and I did not want any part of it. I calculated that wrong because his bomb only went off during the night phase and not the day phase.

Funny enough, nothing from Furby, Fred, adamical, Erage....

Apparently he wasn't lynched, he wasn't a bomb, and malakim2099, our "third" vig, targeted him along with an info gatherer and died.

But he made himself into a bomb and died along with the other two.

Well, see this is sort of why I keep this info to myself, because it just puts a huge target on my back. I didn't want to reveal it at the beginning of the game because for all I knew, there could have been 2 cultist or even more in a game of over 30 people. I haven't played in as many games as most of you have, I'm not saying that as an excuse, but just stating that you guys know the mechanics a little more than I do.

If you really like, someone investigate me tonight and I will search whoever you guys choose tonight.

And you guys do realize that your "personal theories" can pretty much be said about anyone in this game. For all the rest of us know, the both of you could be cult and just got the upper hand on other players and are trying to throw them under the bus. You follow me?

And that whole bomb thing is what made me nervous about voting for him, which is why I didn't.

I think we have run out of investigators in this game....

Yes, this could be true. I see a lot of people viewing the thread, but only 2 or 3 of us talking...

Honestly, it's not a refusal to vote for K-ness. I'm actually quite happy to vote for K-ness.

It's more that if we go for K-ness it will have to be for a kill.

K could be cult. No argument. But it just seems like really lousy play on his part to out himself as a mason, right after a cult has been found, and be cult. However, it could also just be a double blind.


Vizzini: spworldtour: But it's so simple. All I have to do is divine from what I know of you K-ness: are you is he the sort of man who would put the poison cult into his own goblet or his enemy's? Now, a clever man would put the poison cult into his own goblet, because he would know that only a great fool would reach for what he was given. I am not a great fool, so I can clearly not choose the wine in front of you. But you must have known I was not a great fool, you would have counted on it, so I can clearly not choose the wine in front of me.

viewing = their page may be stuck on this thread. Not an indicator of people who are actually on.

He might actually be masoned with adamical and using that as a ploy.

What exactly is this?

A revision of the "Cunning Challenge" from The Princess Bride.

It's me trying to say that voting on whether or not K is cult is gambling with death. And trying to figure out if he's being clever and hiding his 'cultness' or if he's being straight and trying to prove that he's a 'normal' guy.

Anyways. I have to fly to the US very soon. So we need to get some agreement here or I will just leave my vote where it is.