Just making sure it's easily accessible, if necessary.

I'm not following you.

GFish was lynched. So Frankenjustice killed Ebb (flavor) and wounded Flow (flavor) before falling apart (lynch). Then, the following night, Flow was finished off by Hellspawn (flavor/red herring).

Vlad was lynched. So the Deep One was killed by the League (lynch) and Spiderbo was killed by Hellspawn (flavor/red herring).

There was never an actual Ebb or Flow or Spiderbo. Those are safeclaims/red herrings. Hellspawn isn't actually making kills.

That's the theory, anyway.

Like, the hunter isn't running around killing people. The hunter was probably Frank (living in a cabin with a gun and chopping wood).

Can't be messed with? That's a little vague...

Ah, I see. This is going along with the theory that mafia get killed by lynch and only have one life?

But then vlad was almost definitely an SK... you think all scum function the same way?

I guess I'm just kinda skeptical of this theory. Not that it's particularly relevant at the moment.

I don't buy it. To much has to be fake info. I can't buy it. My instinct says it's wrong, actually, every fiver of my being screams it is wrong.

Why have spiderbro even appear? Why not just say vlad is dead? Why a new character? Why waste hellspawn as flavor? More importantly: why has the justice league killed or been the indirect killer of players for the past three nights?
Hellspawn offs gfish. Gangles offs grinner. Hellspawn takes out vlad.

I am pretty sure hellspawn is in game. Pretty sure he straight chose to kill vlad.

This "justice league ain't got a kill" thing smells of BS.

Idk about serial killers or nightkilled mafia members.

The theory is open to divergent paths. More of a hypothesis, really.

To break it down:
90% sure the endless dopplegangers are bad and GFish was bad all along
75% sure Hellspawn isn't actually a PC/no mafia to town conversions.
50% sure this applies to the serial killer.

Do I have you to blame for my night last night?

There was a looooot of POE lynching last game. Lot of mafia members selling out their teammates and claiming mafia, hoping to turn town. That was fun but I don't think Stranger wanted it to go down that way a second time.

The Justice League eliminated the following players:
Night 1 - Nobody
Night 2 - Flow by Hellspawn (flavor kill, imo)
Night 3 - Realmser by Gangles (misdirected power borrow?)
Night 4 - Skulltula by Hellspawn (flavor kill, imo) and Dreamus by Red/Nightblue (vig?)

Meanwhile, three Justice Leaguers have claimed as themselves.

You think the mafia is claiming themselves, killing 0 or 2 people a night, dragging each other, almost lynching each other.... You think there are six of them already in the game? That's how many have been claimed or have made concrete actions in the writeup by killing or stopping kills.

No. The League is not a mafia. Maybe some of them can kill. Maybe there's a killer traitor among them. But a mafia team? No. Clearly not.

So in this theory:

Gfish was actually Frankenjustice, got lynched, left game D2. Second fake claim character died N3 as flavor to throw us off.

Vlad was Deep One, got lynched, left game D4. Second character (but not one he fakeclaimed) died N4 as flavor.

Dreamus killed N4 by either vig (likely) or SK (unlikely, imo).

Problem now is - why didn't vlad claim Skulltula?

Speak for yourself.

Fair enough I suppose. I did say that before I had fully read the write-up. Also, there is a traitor out there.

Given the opening write-up, there is a traitor. I also agree that Stranger didn't want the selling out to happen again. It was a very easy play to make last go-round.

I would like Roy to weigh in as he can probably shed some light on what happened.

Idk. Probably cause it didn't sound unaffiliated and hard to target.

Or he really was Skulltulla. I mean, sk to town isn't as problematic as long as the SKer doesn't claim to become town.



The other hole is what happens with Dreamus? Do we need to lynch him? Do we expect Hellspawn to off Af or Raven's characters tonight and remove the Dreamus player?

Well, I wasn't Dreamus. I figure full disclosure is useful now. I was The Monkey and I'm already on my second life.

I think something being missed here is the Dani(?) bit from the write-up. She targeted Afr. I'm guessing one of them isn't scum.

My only question would be "Why did that get shown in the write-up?"

Obviously a ghostwrite would be a possibility, but I don't think it reads like one. I'm leaning that Dani 2.0 is IR's possible "shell".

With all of the tracking, RT from yesterday I find it shocking no one took a look at Afr... maybe that info isn't online yet.

@Long Con - what did you learn last night?