adamical is pretty good - I really don't think Silver Lantern has been guided this whole time.

So on Night 2, both Ens and I claimed to target Iceman. Ens claimed to MD him, I claimed to guide him. I was trying to be nice since he was getting annoyed with his actions always being messed with, and inadvertently guided him to his death as he targeted what appears to be a PGO Godzilla, as turdburglar claimed.

It certainly reads like a MD and a guide both targeting Iceman that night. It matches with the claimed actions of both EnsRedShirt and myself.

I guided Silver Nights 4, 5, and 6.

I like how you repeatedly leave out my proven claim. How everyone who makes a list seems to be doing that for some reason.

1. michiganj24-Cerberus / JK
2. Rokk_Krinn - Mother Monster
4. rorschachparadox - Phantom of Opera / PGO
5. gfishfunk -Doppelgangers / lawyer
6. Linkor - RB, It
11. turdburgler47 - Godzilla / PGO
12. adamical - Voodoo Guide
15. malakim2099
21. EnsRedShirt - MD
27. Immortal_Raven

19. Jackofhearts2005 - invisible - Neutral
20. Quebbster - Hyde, Nuetral

2 professed neutrals
2 cult
2-3 mafia?

Don't take offense, people mostly just copy/paste earlier lists.

1. Not proven.
2. I just quoted from the last one and added what I could remember. There. Updated.

Reminding them is getting old too. And I even made a list that had your claim on it.

I pledge allegiance
To the mafia
And their ability to extend the game
And to the unreasonable number
Of P-G-Oes
One forum
Under Mod
I'm invisible
With extra lives and post restrictions
For all
Amen

1. michiganj24-Cerberus / JK
2. Rokk_Krinn - Mother Monster
4. rorschachparadox - Phantom of Opera / PGO
5. gfishfunk -Doppelgangers / lawyer
6. Linkor - RB, It
11. turdburgler47 - Godzilla / PGO
12. adamical - Voodoo Guide
15. malakim2099
21. EnsRedShirt - Plants / MD
27. Immortal_Raven

19. Jackofhearts2005 - invisible - Neutral
20. Quebbster - Hyde, Neutral

2 professed neutrals
2 cult
2-3 mafia?

I'm playing catch-up and I'm ready to pop a vote on you just for the fact you've supposedly been lawyering me but my tally has been going down.

Additionally, your saying you might be Mulder and Scully smacks of someone realizing "too many claims. I'll double up on them."

However, I really wanted to comment on this. If it had been the Supernatural Demon we would have seen the smoke expelled like when Grinner was killed.

Ok, back to catching up...

So you don't trust that I'm a PGO, but you offer me a deal you claim is helpful anyway, which turns out to be useless and extra crappy for a PGO in particular.

This I agree with
I see it as either a busdrive...a hider...or a pusher

Not only that but if its false would be great for one of the factions who needs you dead as if they lack a RB they cant kill you at night or so might need you to take yourself out

Unless all these powers aren't him also claiming a teammates' action. I just don't see how he Guided SL but SL was made to kill himself and it wasn't the Supernatural Demon (no smoke and SL hadn't picked up the swearing trait).

What I find particularly odd about this gift giving is why didn't he give one to SL?