When the Quinjet + resource dial is hit by Gluttony what is the result?

1. Is the Quinjet removed from the game?

2. The dial made inert?

3. Can call-ins still be made?

1. the quinjet is neither a resource attachment or a relic so would not be removed from the game. Only the resource dial is a resource attachment.

2. The resource dial is a resource and would be removed from the game and no longer be able to be used.

3. Since you would no longer be able to use the resource dial, no calling help.

Throw the Quinjet across the room. This errata was issued a few days ago.

Nothing. The resource dial is not a resource attachment. Resource attachments are things like the sins on Pandora's box/rock of eternity or the Phoenix shards. Things that attach to a resource.

I only disagree because the wording for the dial is:

And that Gluttony's wording affects things "assigned" to the target. I'm open to the idea that I'm wrong but that wording is pretty spot-on.

It's still not an attachment.

What he said.

People tend to misread Gluttony's power a lot and think it affects resources (I'm pretty sure I did when he first came out). I'm not sure what it is about the wording that does it, but it is very clear. It affects resource attachments, not resources.

It has little to do with the wording. Players reading it want it to do what they want it to do. Which it doesn't, because it does exactly what it says it does.

This is not true. If the Quinjet somehow lost the resource, it could still call in id characters.

Is there a WK ruling in this? I would need an official one or its up to the current judge... We all know the level of consistency fromwk rules

It's doubtful they'd answer it, because it'd be a bit like asking if a trait is ignored when using Pulse Wave.

Read the power, it explains all there that is needed. And a judge should be able to suss that out.

There's not even an intent question here.

Basically you are going to need another way to cripple the Quinjet. Gluttony's trait won't do it.

Yeah, Gluttony does nothing to the Quinjet and its Resource Dial. There are no attachments for said resource, since the ID cards are not attached to it as they are with the Table/Teleporter.

Also, another example of why you need to quote ALL the effects involved when you ask a question.
Nothing there indicates the resource uses any kind of attachments. The bolded part clearly indicates that ID Cards are used normally.