I'm not saying mislynching Grinner day 2 is bad, I'm saying that spending the majority of the day sifting votes on and off a player that is extremely unlikely to give any immediate info for the town is not productive and lets scum talk in circles instead of having to comment on actual content.

Nobody seems overly town to me at the moment. Skullbrother has seemed to me the most scummy simply because he seems most guilty of the aforementioned talking in circles.

The fact that he also hasn't dropped a vote on Grinner makes me slightly more ok with following through with the current lynch.

Thoughts:

I'm seeing townie gfish and townie JoH in this thread. Also feel good about TSP and pretty good about Roy (although his response to DBoy's claim bothers me). Nifty aight too.

DBoy I think is probably town but he just comes across as so scummy I can't help but view him with suspicion. As a rule I'm really not a fan of "I can't help town" or "I'm definitely gonna be killed you guys" posts.

Grinner train seems premature. He's an analysis player who was asked to give reads like a third of the way through day 2, when there wasn't really any activity day 1. *shrug*

Not a huge fan of anybody trying to sell the Freddy bit. That's why I first voted TSP, and I don't like that adamical brought it back up. I think somebody else might've as well? It's not a lynchable offense by itself but I'm keeping an eye on those players.

Don't like grizzz from his "I don't like this train but I guess I'll join it anyway" post. Smells like scum distancing from a townie lynch.

Quiet players are quiet, and I wish they would be less so, but none of them are acting particularly out of character, either.

Don't like the "Who would've killed Anathae" thing that much either tbh. Seems like a very meta WIFOM, based on a player we don't have a good meta read on since they only play Hybridity and we haven't had one the better part of a year. I'd be more amenable if the N1 kill was somebody like Silver or a Grinnerkin.

Interesting.

Removes the urgency from the Grinner vote. Hopefully will prevent Grinner's Lament.

vote Grinner.

It autocorrected to "cure grinder", which is funny. Hush.

I agree about the Freddy thing: Definitely not. I'm reading it as a magnet kill or a flavorful write up.

Feel like I should elaborate on this before it's taken the wrong way. These posts specifically:
Strike me as someone trying to spin the discussion towards useless meandering. Continual assertion that Afrcngy's post garners attention, including an unnecessary additional vote, then trying to jumpstart a conversation on a very slim possibility.

Gfish has had some odd posting too, but I'm chalking that up to roleplay.

I think that's a good case for getting more info on skullbro

Well, now that we've got additional time

Vote Skullbrother

I'm going to leave my vote on Grinner until he (or something else) convinces me to move it.

He's got an extra day to do it.

Let's see some more rainbows and wild speculation.

What info do you feel out would give us?

Also to be clear I do strongly encourage Grinner to make some reads/analysis, especially given the extra day.

CaptainNifty
grizzzadams
Jackofhearts2005
Immortal_Raven
RenegadeRoy
Space Jawa
Linkor
Gfishfunk
Silver Lantern
DestructoBoy
colonialbob
JohannaMason
TonyStarkPrime
Grinner
SkullBrother47
adamical

vote skullbro for info.

Nice rhyme. It wasn't intentional.

@Nifty

Can you clarify what makes you see Grizzz and Raven as leaning town?

Depends on who's on the lynch and who's not and how he flips. I think voting patterns are extremely important. So much can be gained by them.

I voted for Grinner because he was the most likely suspect (at the time) to give any information as well as being the most likely one to actually get a lynch.

It's callous, but you don't get to be my age without making hard choices.

IR's posting seems townish, and I like his list.

As to grizzz, I'd rather not say, but he get's the benefit of the doubt for now.

You'd honestly be higher, if it weren't for our history in these games. Every time I think your town, it ends up biting me in the ass.